My app was nonsensically rejected for not having enough users yet. Isn't the whole point of the marketplace to help obtain users? When I replied to appeal (directly quoting the no-minimum-user-count statement), I never received a response, and none of the ~dozen GitHub employees I know were either willing or able to help me.
I gave up on the marketplace and just wrote my own Stripe billing, but after two years my app still only barely breaks even on its infrastructure costs. I deeply regret wasting my time building a GitHub app.
Adding insult to injury: my GitHub app is a SaaS CI version of my open source CLI tool, which GitHub internally uses as a core infrastructure component for their DB schema management. 8 months after my GitHub app's launch, GitHub open sourced some Actions code which uses my open source CLI tool to substantially duplicate the purpose of my SaaS app, albeit in a less compelling way (their approach doesn't provide inline annotations, is much slower to execute, and involves contorting the CLI in unintended ways).
Now I keep getting support requests from random users who want help configuring GitHub's action, but don't want to consider ever paying for a simpler-to-install solution with more features. It's extremely demotivating.
Based on my research I wouldn't recommend using GitHub Marketplace in its current state.
I've spoken to a few other GitHub app creators, it's a fairly common experience. I think GitHub Actions are kind of viewed as the preferred alternative by GitHub so that's what they're focusing on.
That sort of delay can kill a new product's momentum. I wonder if this is consistent with what others have seen or if it's something unique to this project?