News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by mimimi31 on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:52AM (#27235628)
Why would the Linux Foundation get to decide on if those researchers are allowed to experiment on and waste the time of volunteer developers?
Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by ret2plt on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:57PM (#27236661)
I think it depends on how you frame it. If the Linux Foundation thinks this kind of research would generate useful information for the kernel project, then the developers' time wouldn't be wasted, just used in a different, yet productive, way. I concede that this is not an easy question, because the developers may have different opinions about the usefulness of this exercise, but at the end of the day, maintainers can run their projects how they see fit.
Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by hinkley on Friday May 21, 2021 @11:59AM (#27235760)
The Linux foundation is in a position to ensure that Linux users don’t accidentally get experimented on when the PRs are approved.
Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by dec0dedab0de on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:16PM (#27236003)
Why would the Linux Foundation get to decide on if those researchers are allowed to experiment on and waste the time of volunteer developers?

Granted, In the case of linux, it might make more sense if it were the combination of the Linux Foundation & Linus. It's their project, they can subject their volunteers to any tests they want. It may drive away some volunteers, but wether to take that risk or not, is up to the project to decide. For something as big as the kernel they may decide to get permission from the individual maintainers, maybe even limit the research to only the subsystems that agree to participate.

In any case, the point I'm trying to make, is that this kind of testing may be beneficial, if the project is aware of it, and agrees to it. Who gets to decide on behalf of the project, would depend on the hierarchy of each project.

Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by ghaff on Friday May 21, 2021 @05:14PM (#27240050)
There are relatively few volunteers working on Linux. They mostly do it for their day jobs. Though the same criticism applies with respect to wasting time at their various companies. But, yes, there may have been some way of conducting a useful test after receiving permission--probably on a limited subsystem or set of subsystems.
Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o... by jfrunyon on Friday May 21, 2021 @12:23PM (#27236104)
Presumably they would do so after consultation with kernel developers, like uhh... themselves.