If you a) have an encrypted chunk of data that's 1TB, b) when subpoenaed, hand over only 50GB worth of data, and c) are using a tool that is known of it's ability to offer "hidden volumes" to supply plausible deniability, you can be damn sure that a judge is going to find that suspicious.
The more relevant question is: is it suspicious enough to permit the judge to issue a contempt citation? Well, that's a question for the lawyers, but I'd sure as hell hate to be the test case.
And no, that's not how contempt works. IANAL but Wikipedia says this: To prove contempt, the prosecutor or complainant must prove the four elements of contempt: Existence of a lawful order The contemnor's knowledge of the order The contemnor's ability to comply The contemnor's failure to comply
There's no way to prove your ability to comply with decrypting a hidden volume for as long as it remains hidden.
http://forums.truecrypt.org/viewtopic.php?t=23969 Comments: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/i8dqh/true_crypt...
Hopefully you paid cash, otherwise, they'll know when you bought it. That means no NewEgg. Damn.
Then, you just need to be comfortable saying that you bought a 1TB hard drive, encrypted the whole thing (despite the obvious speed hit it'll take, which you know if you're smart enough to use TC), just to throw a few gigs of porn on it. Hopefully you have a wife or significant other, since no single guy is going to encrypt his porn. Not sure how women treat their porn stashes; it just has to be believable. Also, make sure you don't load the porn on all at once - that'll be very, very suspicious. It'll have to look like an organically-grown stash.
Given all that, if you can lie well, you might be able to convince an investigator that you (as a suspect in something) have an innocent hard drive on your hands. And you should practice, because if the cops aren't convinced and can't force you to hand over the password (due to plausible deniability), you'll probably need to convince a jury.
The question is whether, upon finding a volume which is vastly oversized compared to the non-hidden data, you believe that there are no hidden volumes. If your hidden volume is small relative to your normally-encrypted volume, your believable deniability is much better. But if the important stuff is all on the hidden volume...