Re:$4.5 B. Nortel Bid Shows the Disastrous State of Software...
by jbooth on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:00AM
(#2729823)
Kind of late here, but I think the point with software patents is that the majority of cases tend towards the "wrong" result, basically every case except for maybe novel encryption/compression algorithms.
Re:$4.5 B. Nortel Bid Shows the Disastrous State of Software...
by anamax on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:08PM
(#2731585)
> I think the point with software patents is that the majority of cases tend towards the "wrong" result
That's the claim, but there hasn't been much supporting evidence other than "that doesn't deserve a patent". The vast majoritiy of the "that was obvious" claims are pure hindsight. (Yes, some software patents have been overturned because of prior art, just as happens in other fields.)
I particularly like the "that's just math" (which is often claimed wrt RSA). You never hear someone says "that's just chemistry" wrt chemical application patents. (You can't patent chemistry any more than you can patent math.)
So? Every law has cases where it comes to the "wrong" result.
More to the point, the overwhelming number of "non-practicing" inventors just want to get paid. You seem to think that they shouldn't get paid.
Note that inventors sell to trolls because trolls are better able to get paid. If you weren't so opposed to inventors getting paid, we could look at ways for inventors to get paid without getting trolls involved.