> Partial upgrades are explicitly unsupported by the distro. Pacman allows you to do this, but you're on your own.
Definitely correct, the issue is when you're trying to install a package to get something done, and suddenly your faced with the proposition of either upgrading your whole system while trying to get work done or attempting to upgrade just the required libraries. The latter often carries less risk, but occasionally is very problematic.
> And this is why as an Arch user you will be nudged by experience to use software that gives a crap about quality.
The issue is that this is true of so many very major pieces of linux software. Upstream vendors don't necessarily test their stuff in a ton of contexts, plenty of bugs occur in the kernel/xorg/wayland/gnome/glibc/python/etc. All of these are very mainstream projects that are difficult to avoid.
I found more problems using e.g. debian stable. Upgrades were totally black box and anything could break spectacularly. This was most commonly caused by mixing up to date software you build yourself and the stable repos. Arch on the other hand updates happen daily, and for me, unattended. If I ever do find issues (rare to never), backups fix it.
For any definition of stable.
I may be wrong, as my default is to -Syu any package I install, but doesn't -S install the version of the package compatible with the last time you updated your repos? It's -Sy that can cause problems.
> Partial upgrades are explicitly unsupported by the distro.
The problem is obvious. Sometimes you might have to pin a package version because the newer version does not work with your hardware driver, as you said, but then again Arch calls this unsupported.
I had the same problem in the past, not with Nvidia but with DisplayLink. For that reason I always leave a USB stick with a bootable Arch ISO in my Thinkpad, so that I can arch-chroot and repair the system. It happens rarely, but it happens to me and others as well.
> - Arch will release a new version of Xorg before the graphics card vendors release new drivers that are compatible with it. Same for kernel versions too.
You accidentally put a plural in "vendors", but in practice this is just Nvidia.
If you are forced by circumstance to deal with an Nvidia card, use the LTS kernel and most of your problems go away, and you can also pin your X.org version and manually update it. The real solution is to use a GPU vendor that has mainline drivers, the only valid reason nowadays not to do that being CUDA or being unable to acquire hardware with mainline support.
> - I've had gedit start crashing in new minor versions of gnome due to a setting being incompatible, needing to track that down and unset
That's a gedit bug. Complain to gedit devs or stop using it.
> - If you have python virtualenvs for development and system python is upgraded to a new major version, all your virtualenvs break
You should not be using system python for non-system tasks. Use asdf, Nix, Docker, pyenv or a similar tool for projects requiring their own non-system environment.
> - If arch upgrades the major version of[...]
Partial upgrades are explicitly unsupported by the distro. Pacman allows you to do this, but you're on your own.
> - If you do a full system upgrade and have AUR stuff installed
AUR is not Arch, it's up to each AUR maintainer to keep their scripts up to date and you as a user to keep up with those external dependencies. A common approach is to use an AUR helper to handle both system and AUR upgrades.
> - In general (not specific to arch linux), new versions of software break stuff all the time. You tend to hit way more of this on arch if you keep your system up to date.
And this is why as an Arch user you will be nudged by experience to use software that gives a crap about quality.