You don’t need to know the proper terminology for it or be able to do a full formal/Riemannian analysis or something, but you are using and systematising a kind of music theory directly, even if just on your own idiosyncratic terms
Yes, absolutely. Likewise, a self-taught programmer isn’t totally ignorant of complexity and data structures, they just have their own idiosyncratic understanding of them.
I guess when I say “knowing music theory” I really mean “formal music education”. You’re totally right that somebody like McCartney understands music at a deep level -- and in a knowledgeable way, not simply intuitively. But I still think it’s important to note that he doesn’t read music, doesn’t feel the need to, and has still been massively successful.
Similarly, you can be self-taught in software engineering and still be massively successful, even if you’re weak on some of the areas that would be covered in a formal CS degree.
I think the key question is whether there’s some part of formal CS education that’s essential to success at the biggest tech companies. I guess I’m arguing that there’s really nothing essential, although there’s a lot that’s very useful; and that it can be picked up in other ways.
I think that’s similar to what you’re arguing for in music theory -- even if you don’t have formal classical training, you can still “learn music theory” through practice, collaboration and self-reflection.
the idea of ‘natural talent’ - although no doubt people have very different mental furniture/natural aptitude’s - is one of those things that can be very damaging to people progressing/learning about stuff I have found…
Yes, you’re right. I used to think talent was essential in programming -- that there are just people who “get it” and people who don’t. That’s how it seemed to me in the first year of my CS degree, anyway. But I’ve since realised that what I saw as “talent” was simply “did programming for a hobby as a kid”, i.e. had a head start of 5–10 years of self-directed practice.
There’s clearly a cluster of related things. If you practice more you’ll tend to get better; if you enjoy it you’ll tend to practice more; if you have “talent” you’ll tend to enjoy it more; if you have exposure at a young age that can manifest as “talent”; and so on.
At least in pop music, plenty of successful bands (maybe even the majority) don’t know music theory, they just know how to make music that sounds great (through natural talent and/or hard work).
There’s even a school of thought that music theory is actively bad for pop musicians, as it will tend to steer you down well-trodden lines and stifle innovation. For example, Paul McCartney supposedly avoiding learning any music theory when he was learning the piano, specifically to avoid losing his originality. He got the words for Golden Slumbers from an old piano piece belonging to his sister, but had to write an awesome new melody for it because he couldn’t read the music! (see https://www.the-paulmccartney-project.com/song/golden-slumbe...)
I think the analogy still works, though. To play in an orchestra you absolutely do need to be an expert sight-reader, and ideally have a good grounding in music theory. So working at Google or Facebook would be analogous to playing in an orchestra. They don’t want buskers, they want somebody who can read and understand a Messiaen score.
And maybe a small startup is more like a rock band -- you can get along perfectly well without any theory training. But if you want to grow into an orchestra (or in tech terms, more like 100 or 1000 orchestras) some theory training is essential.
Also, even in a small group, a mix of backgrounds can be beneficial -- look at the Beatles again, where George Martin’s classical training was a significant part of the overall mix (not to say a key part; Martin was the fifth Beatle at best).