News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by coliveira on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:03PM (#27197667)
This gives additional evidence to my personal hypothesis that the normal state of living beings is sleeping. The awake state only appeared as a survival strategy, to better adapt to the natural environment.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by outworlder on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:01PM (#27198565)
> The awake state only appeared as a survival strategy, to better adapt to the natural environment.

Well. Given that "awake" creatures react to stimuli, that might not be too far off the truth. If we could passively survive and not have to forage or hunt for food, what's the point of 'waking up'?

Sleeping is advantageous (less energy use). Efficiency is usually selected for, unless there's some other kind of environmental pressure.

Maybe that's why we haven't found other civilizations. They are all 'sleeping'. Maybe consciousness is also unnecessary (on that front, I love https://rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm)

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by ASalazarMX on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:49PM (#27199262)
While Peter Watts' writing feels like he enjoys being intentionally abstruse, his books are very thought provoking. I still get reminded about the concepts in Blindsight from time to time, years after I read it.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by moonchild on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @02:33AM (#27205299)
Only awake beings can reproduce.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by dormento on Thursday May 20, 2021 @08:54AM (#27220465)
That we know of, yes.

In the earth animal kingdom, yes.

But what if there was some king of being that "shed" their spawn in a totally passive manner, perhaps using all that surplus energy from not needing to be awake most of the time?

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#27197981)
Depends what you focus on as your definition of "living beings". If you look at our cells, they behave more naturally while we sleep. While we sleep, they're "awake". So yes, that's their natural state.

But the "multicellular organism" mode they switch while we're awake is necessary for them to be more than a pile of cells. Which indeed is very important for our survival, as complex behaviors that only multicellular organisms have, are crucial to our ability to adapt.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by wfn on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:18PM (#27197897)
This is basically what Matthew Walker (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_Walker_(scientist)) sort of alludes to in his book, "Why we sleep". It's a good book. He specifically mentions hydras as well (iirc)... he's a neuroscientist who is a crazy maniac about sleep and he cites newest research and delivers a very clear message of urgency.

Lots of fascinating stuff there, highly recommend if you're interested.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by pamplemoose on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:25PM (#27198029)
Important to note there has been pushback on Matthew Walker's writing. Feel free to read more from Alexey Guzey [1] or Andrew Gelman [2].

[1]https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/ [2]https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/03/24/why-we-sle...

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by wfn on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:26PM (#27199766)
P.S. are you familiar with Walker's response as well? https://sleepdiplomat.wordpress.com/2019/12/19/why-we-sleep-... I'll familiarize myself later, and thank you again
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by wfn on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:29PM (#27198092)
Hey, thanks, I'll check it out! Haven't gotten around to reading critique of Walker, but I should. Thank you
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:24PM (#27198002)
What is his clear message of urgency?
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by wfn on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:34PM (#27198177)
In my view (of his view) - that in many cultures we see today, we've come to vastly underestimate the importance of sleep. For example, we've removed afternoon naps from workday routine (with field evidence showing effects on health such as heart disease (against comparative groups who haven't stopped taking naps - but not lab-controlled I think) etc.) We sleep less.[2]

We shouldn't be asking what's the purpose of this pesky thing called sleep (which evolution turns to always incorporate into animal life, however inconvenient it is[1]; to route around the inconveniences as it were, rather than the other way around). We should rather be asking, is there a single function which isn't improved by sleep (Walker thinks no). End of preach rant :)

[1]: e.g.: some birds appear to sleep in patterns such as when there's a row of birds sleeping, the two birds at each end sleep with one hemisphere each - but opposite ones - so that the field of vision is maximised. At midpoint in time however they swap places. The rest of the birds sleep with both hemispheres. That sounds pretty cool.

[2]: though apparently there's criticism directed at Walker re: this, and re: him not mentioning that mortality appears to increase beyond the 7 hour mark (but I'm just learning this, so basically, just a fair warning not to take all of this at face value, there's nuance).

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:51PM (#27198410)
Ah, I align with him then.

Regarding mortality and the 7 hour mark, this is such unfortunate bullshit, that keeps being propagated by people who should know better. Ill people sleep more (even if you catch a cold, once you get past the peak, you sleep more for a few days) because their body requires more recovery.

In chronically ill people this continues for a long time and the body never is able to catch up to the problem it's trying to solve.

But despite all the "correlation not causation" mantras repeated by everyone, we keep citing this as if we decide to sleep a bit more that'll make it more likely to die, which is nonsense.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by wfn on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:57PM (#27198512)
Ah okay, so basically you're saying that the mortality vs > 7 hour sleep time correlation claim hasn't normalized / accounted for other parent causes (e.g. chronic illness and other things affecting / disturbing sleep quality)? I'm a noob here, but if that is the case, that is very unfortunate and frustrating.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:04PM (#27198618)
I've not seen a single study to demonstrate causative link, or conclusively eliminate other variables (which is frankly quite impossible anyway).

Unfortunately a lie repeated a thousand times (by media) becomes truth. And it's just too juicy of a news to say "sleeping too much bad for health". Especially managers, they love that kind of news ;-)

BTW my frustration is pointed at general media and society, not you in particular, I wasn't clear.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by tinyhouse on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:07PM (#27198673)
Regarding naps. Pretty much every sleep expert I heard or talked to is against naps during the day. Mostly because it disturbs night sleep.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @01:23AM (#27204875)
In toddlers and in very elderly, the sleep-wake cycle can no longer be full 24 hours due to decreased/lower abilities of your body to “buffer” for that amount of time. So a single well defined afternoon sleep can be good.

I wouldn’t call that “naps”. That’s not what it is.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by TylerLives on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:15PM (#27197853)
What do you mean by "the normal state of living beings"?
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by vmception on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:26PM (#27198036)
It means that being aware of surroundings with continual sensory input and influence is the aberration.

This matches some other theories as well, where humans and a few other always awake organisms are the extreme, due to selective pressures. For example, humans "feel bored" because having nothing pressing to do for survival is usually the wrong option. Whereas that isn't true for many other organisms and they likely wouldn't have an opinion about staying still in the same place for prolonged periods of time.

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by serverholic on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#27197992)
Surely you understand that most people consider being awake to be our default state and sleeping is just something that we need to do sometimes
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by slver on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:26PM (#27198038)
The way you phrased is reminded me how blindly we walk through life, doing things that our body forces us to do, because despite all our bravado about how smart we are... we really have no clue what we do and why we do it most of the time.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by twhb on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:48PM (#27198363)
A fascinating idea.

For your hypothesis to work, and I think this is what you mean by the article supporting it, sleep would have had to evolve very early. Because being awake activates a great deal of a modern organism’s complexity, and that complexity wouldn’t have evolved in an always-sleeping organism that doesn’t benefit from it. So either the predecessors were awake, or sleep came before all the complexity that is now activated only when awake.

For the first wakers, then, being awake was little more than a period of increased activity. A boost mode. And indeed we’ve already seen the utility of boost modes across a variety of technology, from CPUs to cars to high output flashlights.

But does that make the predecessors really asleep? To use a very HN analogy, were pre-boost CPUs always idling?

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by gibspaulding on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:22PM (#27198861)
It doesn't seem like too far of a stretch to guess that the earliest life forms would have been pretty passive, absorbing nutrients directly from their "primordial soup" and somehow replicating whenever they've stored up enough. I imagine "life" would have gone on for quite some time before "waking up" and evolving the ability respond to their environment by doing things like relocating to a more nutrient rich area or away from danger.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by coliveira on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:04PM (#27199449)
> But does that make the predecessors really asleep?

Well, not directly, but we can certainly talk about the appearance a distinct state, which would now be called awake state in comparison to previous organisms that had a single state. After this appearance it makes sense to talk about previous life forms as "sleeping".

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by lisper on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:26PM (#27198040)
> the normal state of living beings is sleeping

This is reminiscent of the claim that zebras are black with white stripes (or is it the other way around?)

Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by agambrahma on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:28PM (#27198956)
This is the most weird and interesting hypothesis I've heard in a LONG time !
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by jimmytucson on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:16PM (#27198787)
"Normal" is arbitrary, but since most animals need to be awake to reproduce it's hard to envision enough of them always sleeping for it to be the default.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by coliveira on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:49PM (#27199259)
By the time complex animals evolved, the awake state would already be the norm for survival. So, I guess everything we now assign to complex animals is already dependent on the appearance of an awake state.
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by dennis_jeeves on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @09:41AM (#27208436)
coliveira, you have obviously given this some thought. Any further nuances?
Re:Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains by coliveira on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @12:48PM (#27211179)
I'm not a biologist, so I consider this just my pet theory. But the idea is that one key element of evolution was the appearance of an alert state, which we now call wakefulness. The normal for all organisms was what we now call sleep. Organisms that developed this awake state were obviously able to better adapt to the environment.

Like in many other cases, we can take clues from embryonic development. We know for example that fetuses spend at least 95% of their time sleeping. So we know from pretty early stage that sleeping seems to be the norm. Sleeping is also the most efficient, energy-wise, state for an organism. Even nowadays certain animals are able to hibernate for months. Humans can do this too in extreme situations, it is called comma.

So, when we go to sleep we're not just "recharging". We're going to our normal state, and while it is possible to stay that way for long periods, I never heard of anyone staying awake for more than a few days.