News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by SiVal on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:34PM (#27188738)
I agree. Hydrogen and jet fuel are not "explosive". True explosives contain all the components they need for the reaction. Hydrogen and jet/diesel/gasoline fuel require injected oxygen to burn, and you can create an explosive mixture by mixing it with oxygen or keep it non-explosive if you can keep the oxygen out.

Yes, if exposed to air, hydrogen will mix itself more readily than jet fuel will, but it is also much less energy dense, so it will burn out quickly and cause much less damage. A Hindenburg could not have brought down the World Trade Center buildings.

If you have hydrogen sealed in a fireproof bag of some sort, you can heat the outside with a blowtorch, send giant electric sparks through it, etc., and no explosion if the bag doesn't rupture. Because it's not explosive. If it does rupture, no explosion, but the gas will burn as it rises into air with oxygen that hasn't yet been consumed.

I imagine (would have to be rigorously proved, of course) that if you compartmentalized hydrogen in lots of bagged "cells", and the cell membranes were designed so that even if the neighboring cells all ruptured, encountered air, and burned, the heat would not be enough to rupture an unruptured cell, you could have a safe hydrogen airship. It might even be less vulnerable to certain dangers (ex: shoulder-launched terrorist missile) than an airliner.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by slownews45 on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:05PM (#27189466)
That said, the detonation speed of perfectly mixed hydrogen / air is amazing. If you fill a weather balloon with a mix - get ready for a loud bang. Not good for your hearing (even a small balloon)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMB2VR0087w

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9CI6KSV560

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by SiVal on Monday May 17, 2021 @11:12PM (#27190895)
Sure. Imagine a perfect mix of jet fuel and air in a weather balloon. Or metal shavings. Or a perfect mixture of wheat and air in a silo. BANG!

Now imagine a metal aircraft full of fuel with a cargo of wheat--if you dare. Oh the humanity!

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by slownews45 on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @05:31PM (#27201467)
Hydrogen leaks into confined spaces have done the boom thing. My impression is wavefront speed may be supersonic or somehow drive a lot of intensity (not my area)

Wheat is scary in a silo, but in a 50 lb bag not so much. I liked the cell engineering idea with hydrogen - not sure of weight / etc tradeoffs.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by nickpinkston on Monday May 17, 2021 @08:40PM (#27190068)
Though secondary explosives (TNT, etc.) are usually safer than fuels like jet fuel / hydrogen because they don't explode without a primary explosive percussion and don't ignite as easily.

You're safer crashing a glider full of TNT and lit sparklers than a jet full of fuel.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by userbinator on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:44PM (#27190452)
If it does rupture, no explosion, but the gas will burn as it rises into air with oxygen that hasn't yet been consumed.

All the videos on YouTube of hydrogen-filled balloons (yes, pure hydrogen, not HHO) disagree with you.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by aliswe on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:33PM (#27190693)
Not saying you're necessarily wrong, but it could be that the balloon exploding is mistake for an actual combusting explosion