News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by fastball on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:39PM (#27188158)
Don't we have Helium anyway?
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by echelon on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:54PM (#27188325)
Helium is extremely limited and cannot be manufactured at any appreciable scale (you're not dealing with typical chemistry, but physics. Helium is an element.)

What we have naturally comes from radioactive decay deep in the earth. This will continue for some time, but it's a fixed, slow rate.

Helium evaporates into space. Once it's gone, it's gone for good.

The other options we have are hydrogen (extremely reactive), heated oxygen (also reactive), methane (reactive), ammonia...

It's a hard problem.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by treeman79 on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:57PM (#27189407)
Don’t forget about “null” gas.

Better the hydrogen, a few small technical problems aside.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_airship

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by echelon on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:51PM (#27189791)
That won't work on earth due to weight of materials and material strength requirements. It might work on a dense atmosphere, such as Venus.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by app4soft on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:40AM (#27192134)
> It might work on a dense atmosphere, such as Venus.

Gravity also matters here.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by 123123as1asd12 on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @02:08AM (#27191703)
Implosions would be much worse imo.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by fastball on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:12PM (#27188513)
One more problem that will be solved by fusion energy!
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by zabzonk on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:41PM (#27188795)
> Helium is an element

Nitpick: So is hydrogen.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by cbsmith on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:03PM (#27188977)
Yeah, but only one of them is a noble gas that is rarely bound into molecules that would be found in solid form. As a consequence, it tends to just leak out of the atmosphere without a lot of sources for replenishment.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by vitus on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:06PM (#27188999)
Yes.

More precisely, helium is an element that doesn't readily form compounds. Hydrogen does, and as such can be extracted from, say, water via electrolysis.

The secondary issue with helium is that it's much lighter than air -- this is why helium and neon are both much rarer than, say, argon (which is actually the third-most common element in the air after nitrogen and oxygen).

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by zabzonk on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:10PM (#27189033)
> The secondary issue with helium is that it's much lighter than air

Actually, hydrogen is lighter, and so a better lifting gas, than helium.

https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Lifting_gas#/Hydrogen

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by FabHK on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:42PM (#27189289)
Yes, but while hydrogen (H) has half the mass of helium (He), H is only 8% better than He in providing lift in the air, if I computed correctly (as that is generated from displacing much heavier air), so it's not a huge deal:

He: 0.1786 kg/m^3

H: 0.08988 kg/m^3

Air: 1.225 kg/m^3

Air vs He: 1.0464 kg/m^3

Air vs H: 1.13512 kg/m^3

To put it differently, for helium, the lift is about 86% of the weight of the displaced air, while for hydrogen it's 93%.

Both very good, and both are much better than hot air!

(which gives a lift of only about 25% of the weight of the displaced air, at typical temperatures of about 120 deg C)

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by zabzonk on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:53PM (#27189372)
According to the wikipedia page I linked to:

> In a practical dirigible design, the difference is significant, making a 50% difference in the fuel-carrying capacity of the dirigible and hence increasing its range significantly

But I wouldn't know :)

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by FabHK on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:08PM (#27189480)
Oh, very interesting. The linked TIME article from 1924 (!) gives a bit more detail:

> While helium is exceedingly light as compared with air, it is somewhat heavier than hydrogen. The total lift of a helium-filled dirigible is accordingly some 10% less than that of the hydrogen-filled airship. The difference does not appear important at first sight, but the total lift of the gas carries the structure, the motors and the crew. It is only the last 20% or so that is available for carrying fuel, and hence a difference of 10% in the gross lift may spell a difference of 50% in the fuel-carrying capacity. On long-distance flights this difference is vital.

> Nor is the danger of fire totally eliminated with the use of helium; the gas-tanks and the fuel system generally are still vulnerable. But when a ship is properly designed and carefully handled, the danger of fire is comparatively small, even with hydrogen.

https://web.archive.org/web/20110209024932/http://www.time.c...

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by WalterBright on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:42PM (#27189727)
Note that a contributing problem to the Hindenburg disaster was the exterior canvas paint was chemically about the same as rocket fuel.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by andreareina on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @01:56AM (#27191640)
That's what I remembered, so I was surprised it wasn't mentioned in TFA.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by app4soft on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:38AM (#27192123)
> Both very good, and both are much better than hot air!

No.

Hydrogen is highly explosive/flammable — that is why Helium is preferred.

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by vitus on Monday May 17, 2021 @07:26PM (#27189593)
Yes, both helium and hydrogen are much lighter than air.

But that doesn't significantly impact rarity of hydrogen, as it reacts very readily and is typically found in compounds.

You don't find much hydrogen gas in nature (~1ppm in the atmosphere, vs 5ppm for helium).

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by fatsdomino001 on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:14PM (#27188542)
We can theoretically do vacuum zeppelins, which is of course lighter than helium and unlimited tho it has its own problems too.
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by bentcorner on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:26PM (#27188656)
I was curious about this and it looks like it's currently impossible to have a material that is both strong enough and light enough to support a vacuum balloon:

https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/71027/is-it-poss...

Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by fnord77 on Monday May 17, 2021 @05:21PM (#27188605)
iirc, the germans wanted to use helium at the time, but the US more or less had a monopoly on it and would not sell to germany
Re:Caltech professor helps solve Hindenburg disaster by timbit42 on Monday May 17, 2021 @04:49PM (#27188275)
We don't have an unlimited supply.