Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by hobolobo on Friday July 01, 2011 @12:02PM
(#2718853)
Is that a case of the bank not having the money or just that branch not having the cash on hand?
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by white_devil on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:33AM
(#2721308)
Each branch is supposed to function as a bank, right?
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by burgerbrain on Saturday July 02, 2011 @05:38PM
(#2722500)
Why in the world should a single branch be expected to hold that kind of cash for withdrawn without notice? There is a* huge* difference between "having the money" and "having the money in cash form on location".
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by hobolobo on Saturday July 02, 2011 @11:26AM
(#2721754)
They're not autonomous though - individual branches don't hold the value of all their customers' accounts as cash. You're subject to a daily limit (though you can take more if you give them notice).
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by white_devil on Sunday July 03, 2011 @11:54AM
(#2723880)
Now we're just being pedantic. My point was that each branch should have enough cash to act as a "proper bank", whatever amount of money you'd reasonably expect one to have in its vault.
But I'd sure expect more than 10k euro.
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by burgerbrain on Sunday July 03, 2011 @04:59PM
(#2724585)
If they barely had 10k in their vault, then it logically follows that they almost never need that much (otherwise they would obviously make it a point to keep more). If they rarely need that much, then it logically follows that somewhere at or less than 10k is a reasonable amount to have. There is no sense in taking the increased liability of having more if they don't need to.
Furthermore, acting as a "proper bank" means they do a lot more than just acting as your personal piggy-bank/mattress. If they have all their money tied up in cash, it means they can't actually be preforming real bank activities (investment).
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by white_devil on Sunday July 03, 2011 @05:04PM
(#2724599)
Fair enough. But basically me and a couple of other people on this thread wanted to point out that the banking system is not very sound.
I just chimed in with my anecdote.
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by burgerbrain on Sunday July 03, 2011 @05:33PM
(#2724659)
Your anecdote has more to do with the logistics of running a bank than it does with the soundness of banks though.
Re:Those 500K Bitcoins that caused the flash crash weren't real
by white_devil on Monday July 04, 2011 @06:09AM
(#2726045)
That may be, but it doesn't affect how sound the banking system is.
You think this is enough nitpicking, or do you want to go on?
Last year, a branch office of a large bank in Finland was barely able to produce 10 000 euros in cash when I wanted to withdraw it.
The clerk just didn't realize he shouldn't mention it.
Don't be so sure.