They take off because they are excellent, useful and timely ideas. Unfortunately, people who have strong, timely ideas, like this one, frequently aren't able to find good technical co-founders, probably because of the "ideas are worthless" meme so many hackers love to recite nowadays.
So the ideas take off anyway, but the sites basically don't have the technical architecture that they should and have to be rewritten later.
You really think so? I find that statement sort of amazing. I guess ever the optimist, right?
In the current case, well just because it isn't perfect from a technical standpoint, doesn't mean it wasn't the best execution of the idea out in the wild...
BCrypt 1000 iteration test script: https://gist.github.com/1058610
# => That took 76.370953 seconds
BCrypt 1 iteration test script: (same as above but with `1.times do`)
# => That took 0.074209 seconds
SHA512 1000 iteration test script:
# => That took 0.004092 seconds
SHA512 at 1000 iterations is over 18,000 times faster than BCrypt at similar iterations; which, by the way, makes no sense to do.
BCrypt has a "cost" factor, which is used to adjust the computational complexity to your use case. This is why BCrypt makes so much more sense for password encryption than something like SHA512. Running SHA512 n times is just a cheap, ineffective imitation of BCrypt.
How do these businesses succeed with business people that have no business wit about them, have NO ability to communicate effectively in these critical situations and have awful taste in technical advice?
Google "bcrypt sha-512 hash passwords" and tell me if it's a hard call to make. You should have heard these guys within the first 36-hours answering questions. Even the business guy over at TradeHill, "Well, you know after mtgox, we need to do a lot to beef up our security". Even if that's a true statement, what a ridiculously terrible way to phrase it.
I think speech and debate classes should be required for everyone to graduate highschool, let alone college. People aren't good at thinking on their feet and speaking in critical situations where wording makes a difference.
When you're in the business of being an online bank for an uninsured (nearly) untraceable currency, mis-speaking like this costs you your most important asset: TRUST. That's not even touching the tip of the iceberg of lies and misinformation that has come out of mtgox.
Anyone that leaves a penny in any mtgox account is an idiot.