News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by LatteLazy on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:17AM (#27164521)
It's disappointing to see the tories ("The Conservatives" political party's nickname) knee jerk opposition. It would be nice to see more details on the actual trial (length and amount paid). That said, we basically know UBI works, it's just that no one has the balls to just do it...
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by sokoloff on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:23AM (#27164552)
Do we know that it works? Including accounting for sourcing the funds and the amount of demand-driven inflation that might result?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by notahacker on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:32AM (#27164618)
This. So far we've repeatedly tested that if you give people in an area a small sum of money paid for from central government funds for a couple of years, they won't change their habits much but will be a little better off financially, which should be of absolutely no surprise to anyone. A real pilot would - as a minimum - be making the local tax rises and welfare cuts necessary to make the scheme revenue neutral, which might actually challenge UBI advocates' certainty that it works...
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by LatteLazy on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:44AM (#27164703)
I'm the root commentor but I hope you don't mind me piling on.

It's pretty well agreed that the trial in Finland worked:

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2242937-universal-basic...

Id welcome a trial that included paying for it. That said, I don't think it would make a big difference. The UK (I'm a brit) spends enough on welfare to just give everyone £5000 pa (including kids) at the same price. We could just start there and make zero changes to tax policy...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by sokoloff on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:59AM (#27164794)
All topical comments are welcome everywhere IMO.

If the average is £5K and many are receiving £0, it must be the case that some are receiving much more than £5K in benefits. If you normalize everyone at £5K, what happens to those who were previously receiving some multiple of that? (I’m presuming that £5K is an insufficient amount to meet what society has previously considered their need for support was.)

In essence, you’d be proposing a UBI for ordinary UK citizens to be funded by those who are currently receiving welfare [over £5K]. That would be unpopular with proponents and opponents of UBI I think.

(If half or more of that £5K is in staff and overhead and you were willing to dismantle those organizations as soon as it was clear UBI “would work”, this might be workable. I don’t know how much is direct benefits vs overheads [including eligibility and fraud checks, which would be dramatically reduced under UBI].)

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by notahacker on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:46AM (#27165653)
We could try that experiment. Good luck persuading those pensioners who've lost half a state pension they believe they've earned and single parents made homeless that UBI is a positive change because some other people are better off though. Or getting the Parliamentary votes to even try that...

The Finnish trial "worked" in the trivial sense that unemployed people given an extra £2k a year on top of any other income they might earn were marginally better off. It didn't work in the sense that it was considered worth raising taxes to pay for it to be extended

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Erikun on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:18AM (#27164937)
The Finnish Basic Income Experiment was carried out in 2017–2018. The primary objective of the experiment was to provide information on the effects of a basic income on the target population’s employment, income and use of social benefits. An additional objective was to provide information on the well-being of the recipients of the basic income. 2,000 people who were aged 25–58 and receiving unemployment benefits from Kela in November 2016 were randomly selected to form the treatment group of the basic income experiment. Everyone else who was receiving unemployment benefits at the time formed the control group. The basic income was an unconditional benefit which did not have to be claimed, and for which there were no special conditions. The basic income was paid to the treatment group unconditionally for two years, and was not affected by any income from employment or entrepreneurship. This report includes the results from the sub- studies of the evaluation of the experiment. According to an analysis of the register data, during the one-year assessment period employment in the treatment group on average increased by 6 days more than in the control group. Sub-studies based on survey data analyzed the health, mental well-being, economic situation, trust and experiences with the bureaucracy of the treatment and control groups. With regard to a number of indicators, the well-being of the basic income recipients was better than that of the control group. Qualitative interview research shows, on the one hand, the very different meanings of basic income for one's own employment opportunities and, on the other hand, large differences in the starting points and life situations of basic income recipients. Better opportunities for social participation and increased autonomy were highlighted regardless of changes in one’s own employment. A media analysis found that the basic income experiment was covered in the domestic and international media, above all from an economic and employment perspective. In a population survey measuring support for a basic income, 46 % of respondents agreed or partially agreed with the statement that a basic income should be implemented in Finland.The evaluation of the basic income experiment was carried out by Kela, together with the VATT Institute for Economic Research, the University of Turku, the University of Helsinki, the Labour Institute for Economic Research, the Finnish Central Association for Mental Health and the think tank Tänk.

Abstract of the final Report of the Finnish experiment, mostly in finnish though. https://julkaisut.valtioneuvosto.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/1...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by toyg on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:45AM (#27164708)
If people are not forced to take low-paid jobs to survive, the surplus skimmed by tory-voting classes disappears.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by jokethrowaway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:35AM (#27165076)
It's not the 80s anymore, rich people are mostly liberals these days (especially the ultra wealthy)
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by toyg on Sunday May 16, 2021 @03:58AM (#27172008)
And Boris Alexander de Pfeffel-Johnson is clearly a man of the people. /s

The bedrock of Conservative support, and main source of their rank&file and leadership, is in the owners’ class. Whether they own a pharmacy (Sunak), a shop (Javid), newsagents (Patel), or factories (Osborne), they own; hence they support the mechanisms that generate money for owners.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mc32 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:24AM (#27164558)
By balls, you mean money.

Look at the difficulty the service industry has now hiring people who would rather receive government relief and sit around the house than work a marginally better paying job—it’s not like they are using this time to pursue productive hobbies (pursuing their passions)... and look at the inflation and debt we’re incurring from free money

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:27AM (#27164578)
> Look at the difficulty the service industry has now hiring people

It's easy to hire people, you just have to offer better wages. The issue is that they can't find anybody willing to work for the wage they are offering, which is very different from not being able to find people to hire.

> it’s not like they are using this time to pursue productive hobbies

Any studies on this?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by trentnix on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:46AM (#27164709)
> It's easy to hire people, you just have to offer better wages. The issue is that they can't find anybody willing to work for the wage they are offering, which is very different from not being able to find people to hire.

...because the government is paying them not to work. That's the point. And that means no skills are being trained, no discipline is being developed, and no experience is being attained learning customer service and the basics of business economics.

I worked in a convenience store for minimum wage ($4.25/hour) for four years when I was younger. A little more than a decade later I owned my own retail store. Believe me, it's a long trip from stocking a drink cooler and scrubbing the toilets (what I did on my first day) to opening your own retail establishment. But that story is quite common - many dishwashers become restaurant owners, line cooks become chefs, and stockers become store managers.

Your point about wages isn't really cogent. I'm a degreed Computer Scientist and software professional with decades of experience and I'll flip burgers for the right wage. But most won't be able to afford to buy them and they certainly won't find the cost-value appealing. And when the cost of those burgers goes up, UBI and whatever other creative ways we justify paying people not to work will have to go up too.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by viraptor on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:07AM (#27164849)
> no skills are being trained, no discipline is being developed, and no experience is being attained learning customer service and the basics of business economics.

You're saying that like people on unemployment are only those about to enter the job market. That's not going to be the case - there's lots of people with existing experience who lost jobs. And realistically only a small fragment of that group would advance so the whole missed experience is a bit sus.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by trentnix on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:54AM (#27165266)
> You're saying that like people on unemployment are only those about to enter the job market. That's not going to be the case - there's lots of people with existing experience who lost jobs.

Well of course, but that's not what we're talking about. There are a huge number of service industry jobs that were filled prior to the pandemic that are no longer filled. It appears those people are largely unemployed and apparently happy to stay that way. Such is the expected consequence of paying people not to work.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by sonograph on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:47AM (#27164717)
> The issue is that they can't find anybody willing to work for the wage they are offering

While this is accurate, it ignores OP's point that they were willing to work for those wages pre-pandemic, but now the government is paying them something equivalent to 'sit around' (per OPs point).

Is it the job of the employer to raise wages or the government's job to pay people to work vs sitting? Maybe we should bring back the Civil Works Administration

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:43AM (#27165154)
When people are paid starvation wages and have to have multiple jobs, that's brushed off as "supply and demand" of labor. You get paid what the market is willing to pay for your labor, and it's your own fault if you can't offer anything more compelling to demand a higher wage.

But when the situation is flipped around, and there is a shortage of labor instead? Suddenly the same rules don't apply, "supply and demand" isn't what should rule the price point for labor, instead, these companies are entitled to cheap labor. If people are unwilling to work for the wages offered, it's the people who are defect, not the wages offered.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by sonograph on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:17AM (#27165439)
I don't have the 'correct' answer here, but I think I understand what you're saying. Except the shortage of labor in this case is artificially created. I agree that companies should not be entitled to cheap labor, and I do wish they are paid better though
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:25AM (#27165507)
A fair point, but lots of market situations are "artificial", it's not like a natural disaster caused any of the recent recessions.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mytailorisrich on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:04AM (#27164829)
> It's easy to hire people, you just have to offer better wages.

There is nothing easy in just offering better wages, not least in industries where the bulk of the costs are wages and where productivity is often low.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:49AM (#27165209)
Wages in America have actually been going down the last ten years due to inflation, while the number on the paycheck has stayed roughly the same for a huge segment of society.

Yet nothing was done about this because that's just the market for you, supply and demand, and you just gotta have two jobs if one doesn't pay enough to live. All while American industry has been booming.

But when the hurt happens on the industry instead? When circumstance means that they would have to pay more? That cannot be tolerated, no industry or business should ever have to be in economical turmoil because of shifting economical circumstances, that's only for the little people to deal with.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:50AM (#27164739)
For unemployment at least in our state you don’t even have to show you are looking for a job. Anyone hiring can tell you how hard it was to get people back to work, we’re talking people making $25 per hour refusing to work because unemployment was 60% of their salary plus $600 a week. A person making $30,000 per year was making the equivalent of $49,000 per year instead, and didn’t have to do anything for it. Now it is that plus $300 per week and someone making $30,000 is now still making about $33,000 per year, again without actually having to work or even look. If they do come back they refuse to work more than about 15 hours per week so they can continue to claim unemployment for the rest and get their extra $300 per week.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:54AM (#27165260)
A lot of this is because there has traditionally been an imbalance between employer and employee, where if they stop exchanging labor for money the employer suffers a mild inconvenience while getting a new person hired, while the employee faces the possibility of losing access to food, shelter and medicine for them and their family.

This power imbalance means that the employee will often not complain about having wages stolen, complain about safety violations, or even be able to bargain fairly for the value of their labor. It's real hard to strike a fair business exchange with somebody who has a metaphorical gun pointed at your head.

Due to these unemployment benefits, that gun is gone for a lot of people, and they can push back harder and say that "no, the terms you are offering me for my labor is not good, I will not take this job" and the industries and businesses are losing their shit over this. Economical trouble and turmoil is for the "small people" to suffer, they shouldn't have to offer better wages to navigate a shifting economical landscape, they are entitled to cheap labor.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:13AM (#27165404)
Businesses aren’t worried about paying better wages, they are worried about being unable to produce their goods or services. Sure they can give better wages but now what they are producing has to cost more. Have that happen across all industries and it is inflation. With inflation no one ends up better than where they started, particularly the lowest wage employees will be the hardest hit by inflation.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Drakim on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:30AM (#27165545)
Wages has roughly stagnated while inflation has driven up the price of goods for a long time in America, yet we didn't do anything to help those who had less and less buying power. They simply had to get another job, or if they couldn't, forgo good shelter and medicine. If you can't afford rent, you get thrown out on the street, that's just life.

Meanwhile, despite this downwards trend that's been shrinking the middle class in America, American industry has actually been booming the last ten years. America is richer than ever before, but it's workers are paid (due to inflation) less than they were.

So it's real hard to emphasize with the businesses who are seeing thinner margins because of higher labor costs.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:06AM (#27165853)
That is false. Wages have increased significantly per the chart for median real weekly earnings from the fed. Real means it has been adjusted for inflation and median is the middle wages. Median is better than average because it accounts for uneven distribution of wealth that you claimed is occurring.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mc32 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:02AM (#27165802)
Agreed that low skill labor wages have stagnated due to an oversupply of cheap labor and minimum wage lagging inflation...

But, regardless people are opting to stay home with government benefits over slightly better earnings via work. So they are okay with having less money if it means doing nothing.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by lr4444lr on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:26AM (#27164575)
I do think this is important data, but you've gotta steel-man the UBI argument better: the increased unemployment benefits is not really UBI in that the benefit totally disappears if these people take jobs. UBI is a floor: not an eligibility benefit.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by LatteLazy on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:34AM (#27164633)
Haven't we spent the last decade bemoaning the lack of moderate inflation? Plus the primary issue with inflation is that it hurts people at the bottom, so UBI offsets that inherently.

As for the money, I am brit so I only know the British numbers. We spend about 300bn a year on benefits (in non covid times). That's £5000 per citizen (including kids) and doesn't count a whole bunch of other subsidies (free houses, local government spending etc). So we wouldn't need to raise much additional spending.

Of course, people would be more likely to take service jobs if they could keep their unemployment benefit (as they would a UBI). That's one of the big upsides of a UBI: no benefit trap like we're currently seeing (rightly or not).

And all this is without any uptick in any economic area (people accepting lower wages, getting educated/trained, increased consumption, lower crime etc).

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by mc32 on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:08AM (#27165883)
I think that yes some people would work if they got to keep their UBI but there’d a considerable amount who would be okay to scrape by and do nothing or work part time instead of full time. If I understood my high school cohort, this is okay but it’s an unproductive part of society. Some people are just not motivated.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by LatteLazy on Saturday May 15, 2021 @01:16PM (#27167017)
I think we have a weird attitude to work. The western employment rate is about 50%. 50% of people don't do any form of paid employment.

The truth is, we've just accepted that a big proportion of the population are allowed to opt out despite not having paid in. Sure, some of them are kids. But most aren't.

So we engage in this weird exercise and pretend that for every 10 people, there are 5 workers, 2 deserving unemployed and 3 dirty slackers who lack motivation and should probably be whipped. Excuse my fun hyperbole.

A UBI is just a more honest approach. It treats everyone the same. It doesn't bother forcing unemployed people to pretend they're disabled or that someone a month before their 65th birthday is lazy but someone a month after it is "retired"...

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by TheRealSteel on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:33AM (#27164630)
The service industry in America is having difficulty hiring because they aren't paying enough. That's all their is to it.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by alistairSH on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:38AM (#27164664)
Can you provide some numbers about people taking benefits instead of working? I'm sure there are a small number, but unemployment in the US is currently within a normal range, so I don't see the impact you claim being possible.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:54AM (#27164757)
I replied with numbers to a different comment but to summarize a person making $30,000 per year was making the equivalent of $49,000 per year instead during the extra $600 per week. Now it is $300 per week only and someone making $30,000 is now still making about $33,000 per year, again without actually having to work or even look. If they do come back they refuse to work more than about 15 hours per week so they can continue to claim unemployment for the rest and get their extra $300 per week.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by alistairSH on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:16AM (#27164917)
I was looking for estimated numbers of people actually doing this. Your initial comment seemed to imply a very large number of people opting to remain on unemployment. I don't think that's true, given the current unemployment figures are near historical norms.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:49AM (#27165210)
It’s true it’s getting easier as people see the deadline for the extra $300 unemployment to end in September and are getting worried but we’re still about double the unemployment pre pandemic. Plus with crazy amounts of government stimulus and low interest rates still pumping the economy, jobs are available and money is available. It’s not the best article but I did find below showing job openings are even higher than prepandemic levels while unemployment for some reason (because of the federal benefits I would say) is also higher. https://numbernomics.com/unemployment-vs-job-openings-2/