News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bmelton on Thursday June 30, 2011 @06:59PM (#2716075)
I've been on the wrong end of a couple of projects like this, and in my experience (not necessarily indicative of this case) the customer can be VERY at fault.

I've been dragged into 'feature acceptance meetings' that literally dragged out for weeks when testing of a new chat component devolved into a days-long discussion on whether the graphic in the header (provided by the customer) was appropriate. The unspoken issue proved to be that they didn't want us to use 'barren trees' in the picture of their building. We switched the photo used from one taken in winter to one taken in summer. This took something like 400 man-hours to resolve, after which we achieved signoff, but at the expense of having met budget.

Another instance on the same product was feature creep to the extreme. We had originally won a firm-fixed contract, meaning we would build products a, b and c for x dollars, and if it cost us more, it came out of our pocket. If it cost us less, we pocketed the profits. The customer decided, on day 1, that they actually wanted a lot more features than were described in the project scope defined, and that we won a legally binding contract to perform. Out of accomodation, we changed their product to a time-and-materials contract, meaning we had a fixed markup on labor and a minimal markup on hardware / tangibles. This then involved them dragging the project out for years longer than anticipated and signing invoices all the way, then griping at us on the budget near project completion and asking for a bunch of free labor (which is illegal under their new contract). The problem in that case was that the project management and senior execs changed repeatedly. We were at first working with their Office of Science and Technology, then with Information Services, then with Public Affairs. Each of these department changes involved swapping our equipment out so that we could have appropriately charged-back equipment to the appropriate department, which meant weeks of non-work. Each department had a different spin on what they wanted out of the project. We spent 8 months and thousands of man-hours implementing a very elegant services oriented architecture that could surface all of their legacy systems to a single web portal. Then we changed departments, and they literally told us to turn that feature off, and instead focus on a visual redesign. We implemented a single sign on service that we integrated with our product, but could be extended to work with literally every system in their enterprise. It was abandoned due to a department change.

During the first phase of the project, we'd worked with the customer to build out their data center. They wanted a new data center because the division that owned the project was going to be adding a bunch of other programs to integrate with what we were building. They spent over a year on construction, converting a service garage into a data center. They bought millions of dollars worth of EMC storage hardware and Cisco routers. Then they realized that they didn't have any budget planned for out-year maintenance, so they moved the venue. That was somewhere in the realm of $50 million dollars that was literally just thrown away, as the last I heard, they were re-converting the data center back into a garage.

In short, government contractors catch a lot of flack, because they control the visibility of these things. The contractors often can't speak to details of these projects due to security clearances or NDAs, and at the end of the day, the government is always happy to blame the vendor. It's well practiced, and designed with a variety of scapegoat clauses built in.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by joe_the_user on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:37PM (#2716758)
Great stories...

... it's just the article notes a subcontractor has already been convicted of fraud and kickbacks, so this might not have been a project quite like the projects you describe (though if this is a Terry Childs-type case, I'd love to hear about it).

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bmelton on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:41PM (#2716771)
Sorry, I meant to imply that that's just the way things are, however, after the realization that he'd been convicted, it's likely that whether he's done anything wrong on this particular project, he's drawn the scapegoat straw.

I meant to say those things, but got lost in typing so much other nonsense and trailed off. Thanks for bringing it up.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by nkassis on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:55PM (#2716985)
I wouldn't be so sure. One thing that working in government has taught me is that the bad contractors seem to be equal or greater proportion to the good.

They would bid on something if they weren't going to find a way to make more than what the original contract was for because in the bid wars they often lower the bids so much they have to recoup somehow. In this case they probably did not build the recoup method into the contract and did it illegally.

At least that's my theory.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bugsy on Friday July 01, 2011 @12:24AM (#2717051)
What you describe is not really the "wrong end", that is the standard way that projects are done by government.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by josephcooney on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:02PM (#2716501)
This plus 10. The government projects I've worked on were all like this on a macro and micro level.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by zaidf on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:45PM (#2716438)
Wow, sounds a lot like our university's tech overhaul, especially the single signon stuff.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by nkassis on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:56PM (#2716991)
The idea of single sign on isn't bad, it's just a pipe dream with all the services and crappy software accumulated over the years.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by nl on Friday July 01, 2011 @08:12AM (#2717954)
Everywhere I go I end up on SSO projects. I always swear I'll avoid them, but they seem to jump out at me when I least expect it.

Your assessment of the software and services seems fairly accurate to me (there are a couple of exceptions: CAS is simple enough to be easily understandable and works ok, and Atlassian Crowd looks ok too).

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by protagonist_h on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:26PM (#2716359)
what? it took 400 man hours to replace a logo?
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by arctangent on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:35PM (#2716395)
From personal experience I can confirm that this is exactly how it works when governments try to do things. There's such a compulsive need to negate risk that everything is all about the process instead of the results - and inevitably this leads to huge amounts of wasted time and money while people try to decide the right thing to do.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by harisenbon on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:26PM (#2716899)
On a previous project for a very large automaker, it took me 5 full days plus a 1 week trip to 4 cities in China to change a single graphic. (The rational was that they wanted the client to talk directly with the engineers instead of having to go through all the corporate bureaucracy. So much for that. ;)

And then they changed it back to the original.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by gnaritas on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:30PM (#2716375)
400 man hours to decide to replace a logo, big difference. That's what you get when you design by committee.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bmelton on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:35PM (#2716394)
Exactly right.

Replacing the logo itself took all of about 30 minutes (receive new picture, digitally retouch, overlay onto background image, resize, play around with transparency, save to png.)

Also, bear in mind, the 400 hours is 400 man-hours, which is a cumulative number based on the number of people involved. If you've never done business with government, let me assure you, it was a lot more people than necessary.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by zaidf on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:48PM (#2716450)
Absolutely. The man hours can easily pile up when you do a conf call with a half dozen folks where majority of them are on mute 90% of the time.

I recently did contract work for an agency and had instances where a simple spacing or image resizing took days of work because the client or the agency would understand and then forget that I must crop and/or resize images for them all to be of one size.