Re:Cloudflare’s CAPTCHA replacement with FIDO2/WebAuthn is a...
by livueta on Friday May 14, 2021 @04:35PM
(#27159400)
That's unfortunately not true at all in my experience. Maybe if you're an anodyne SAAS, but if you host any user-generated content, especially if it's adjacent to gaming (my personal experience was mostly with gaming-related forums and IRC networks), politics or any other charged topic, expect to get hammered on a pretty frequent basis. IoT botnets are pretty easy to rent at this point, so the attack is accessible to every skid known to mankind.
I actually agree with your overall point as I try to use Tor for a lot of "normal" browsing, but I'm not sure what the correct solution to accommodate both is. It's a hard problem, and having been in that position myself I have a hard time faulting small website operators who have no alternative defenses.
e: just to add to this, I see the existence of ddosing as a significant driver towards centralized monolithic services. If your blog on Palestinian rights or whatever is getting hit, that's an incentive to move it to a platform that takes care of networking for you. It's a little absurd to go all-in on decentralized self-hosting without at least an acknowledgement that with current tech and typical personal-computing budgets, doing so is giving a heckler's veto to literally everyone. Cloudflare isn't the only dimension things can be centralized along.
I actually agree with your overall point as I try to use Tor for a lot of "normal" browsing, but I'm not sure what the correct solution to accommodate both is. It's a hard problem, and having been in that position myself I have a hard time faulting small website operators who have no alternative defenses.
e: just to add to this, I see the existence of ddosing as a significant driver towards centralized monolithic services. If your blog on Palestinian rights or whatever is getting hit, that's an incentive to move it to a platform that takes care of networking for you. It's a little absurd to go all-in on decentralized self-hosting without at least an acknowledgement that with current tech and typical personal-computing budgets, doing so is giving a heckler's veto to literally everyone. Cloudflare isn't the only dimension things can be centralized along.