Re:Julian Barbour’s ideas about time and the universe have r...
by tsimionescu on Friday May 14, 2021 @02:08PM
(#27157643)
> It has time, but again, Barbour is arguing time is extra baggage which is unneeded when you have the motion of the particles - as above. It adds nothing.
This is the part that seems suspect: it seems like motion is taken to be fundamental, but time is not. This seems just as arbitrary as taking time as fundamental, and motion as derived (simply the totality of positions at different points in time).
But overall, given the position and momentum of a particle at step 1, can you predict its position at step 6 without knowing some quantity that is equivalent to the length of time between step 1 and step 6? And if you do require such a quantity, does it matter whether we use time or something else?
> A flow of time is the subjective feeling of a continuous you "flowing" through time.
Sure, but there is much more to time than this human subjective experience. A lot of our knowledge of physics relies on the notion of time to actually function. It's true that we already know that some of our fundamental physical theories are flawed (since they are currently incompatible with each other), and perhaps removing time from them COULD be a necessity for unifying them, but this is far from a given.
I very much doubt you could reformulate special relativity without ending up with a concept that is completely isomorphic to what we think of as time.
Note that a physical representation of a continuous "you" is a much more dubious concept than time itself, and I think it is one that is anyway incompatible with most physical theories/interpretations, as arguments like the Ship of Theseus or teleportation have shown forever.
This is the part that seems suspect: it seems like motion is taken to be fundamental, but time is not. This seems just as arbitrary as taking time as fundamental, and motion as derived (simply the totality of positions at different points in time).
But overall, given the position and momentum of a particle at step 1, can you predict its position at step 6 without knowing some quantity that is equivalent to the length of time between step 1 and step 6? And if you do require such a quantity, does it matter whether we use time or something else?
> A flow of time is the subjective feeling of a continuous you "flowing" through time.
Sure, but there is much more to time than this human subjective experience. A lot of our knowledge of physics relies on the notion of time to actually function. It's true that we already know that some of our fundamental physical theories are flawed (since they are currently incompatible with each other), and perhaps removing time from them COULD be a necessity for unifying them, but this is far from a given.
I very much doubt you could reformulate special relativity without ending up with a concept that is completely isomorphic to what we think of as time.
Note that a physical representation of a continuous "you" is a much more dubious concept than time itself, and I think it is one that is anyway incompatible with most physical theories/interpretations, as arguments like the Ship of Theseus or teleportation have shown forever.