News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by thematt on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:11PM (#2715553)
Although New York has "received a working system that will advance our management ability ... because the project was apparently tainted by fraud and kickback schemes, the City must be made whole"

...

The city is also planning to launch a request for information (RFI) process in January in search of alternative timekeeping systems.

Wow. So they eventually got a working system. Now they're throwing it away and going to purchase a new one? Meanwhile turning 83 contractors into FTE's to maintain the existing system? This seems like complete craziness for something as commoditized as timekeeping software.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by kenjackson on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:41PM (#2715665)
Timekeeping systems are actually extremely complicated. EXTREMELY sophisticated. The level of detail it takes to get one right is painstaking, and it is key to a city's survival. It's complex enough that you wouldn't understand it, nor would any auditor.

For that reason, I just started a new startup company: TimeKeep NYC. We specialize in timekeeping software for NYC area cities. Looking for employees now, especially ones who aren't snitches. Based on past products in this market, I think we can do quite well.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by jerf on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:01PM (#2715722)
To be fair, timekeeping software really isn't as trivial as you might like, at least assuming that we want to move beyond the raw recording of who worked when out into actual management of such things. Requirements come from federal, state, and local laws, as well as negotiations with all relevant unions. So even before you've gotten to the usual BS requirements laid on by management, you've already got a large pile of requirements that A: are legally mandated and B: written without so much as five minutes consultation with a software engineer.

But, yeah, on the other hand that's just the usual business software story. 10x budget overruns are probably not called for.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by ams6110 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:35PM (#2715811)
But, really.... timekeeping and payroll were some of the FIRST business applications developed. It's a solved problem at this point, even with all the nuances. Developing this from scratch for NYC seems like the epitome of reinventing the wheel.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by mattmanser on Friday July 01, 2011 @07:13AM (#2717819)
No enterprise software is a solved problem yet, there's a lot of bad software dominating at the moment (look no further than sage for accounting for example), any enterprise software you randomly pick will suffer from at least one of:

- Have bloody awful UIs

- Aren't extensible

- Need a massive amount of expensive consultant days to setup

- Are very brittle

- Have an overwhelming list of features which make them very hard to use

- Have bizarre restrictions on certain data (e.g. max 100 chars for a comment)

- They're not capable of talking with common system X

- Don't expose an API

- Have atrocious db structure making reporting extremely expensive in dev time

- Use a home rolled DB (oh. god. no.)

As for the problem of timekeeping being extremely complex, it's not at all. It's difficult, but solvable with one or two decent developers/project managers in a few months. I know as I've seen it done twice now.

It's only extremely complex if you try and include every weird quirk and feature that every client has ask for. Sometimes the solution isn't extending the software, it's changing the business process or simply leaving them on the old paper system.

If you take a 37signals-esque path you've got something that'll sell to 80% of businesses, let niche software cover the rest.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by jerf on Friday July 01, 2011 @11:23AM (#2718688)
"It's difficult, but solvable with one or two decent developers/project managers in a few months. I know as I've seen it done twice now."

It was actually my first task that I ever did "for real", though we did only the raw recording; the processing was done by older code that had all the quirks built in. It was a success, too. The problem itself is easy, but it's definitely in the class of things that can be made arbitrarily hard by added requirements with no thought given to costs/benefits. Fortunately on my project, the devs and the management were on good terms, so much thought was given to cost/benefit tradeoffs, but I can easily see cascading failure in a different environment. Even the easiest software projects can and are sunk by that.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by jfruh on Friday July 01, 2011 @12:50PM (#2719074)
"If you take a 37signals-esque path you've got something that'll sell to 80% of businesses, let niche software cover the rest."

Er, has it occurred to you that the insanely convoluted world of NYC government might constitute a niche?

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by anon7865 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @07:39PM (#2716214)
> especially ones who aren't snitches

The brazenness...only in NYC.

Also, if you ever get in the position of saying "X is extremely complicated and I can't explain it to you" it is because you stand to benefit by designing a system poorly, or you aren't bright enough or don't have the experience to realize that you can reframe the problem. Algebraic geometry is also complicated, but these days there are plenty of books that will explain it to you, and the tools (like sheaves) are well-established and standard.

Obfuscation is the MO of installed, configured enterprise software. If there were an incentive to create a simple, effective solution, then, lo and behold, one would be created. The incentive is almost never there.

Take Unix for example. It is simple and effective (and flimsy as all heck) but before it came along, obtuse operating systems were the norm. It is worth pointing out that A) Thompson and Ritchie are geniuses and B) there was no financial incentive.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by billt on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:48PM (#2715875)
They are more complex than this. Not just anyone can start a company to provide 99.9% reliable enterprise-level management of this problem. A recent study indicated that a major city would have to spend at least $100M to tackle this systemic issue. NYC's mistake was trying to cut corners with $60M.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bmelton on Thursday June 30, 2011 @07:03PM (#2716089)
Have you already looked into DCAA compliance? If not, your system can't be used for any federal systems, and likely aren't available to be used by most state and municipal government agencies.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by lylejohnson on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:07PM (#2716847)
I'm going out on a limb and guessing that kenjackson (grandparent post) was kidding about his new startup.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by clistctrl on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:11PM (#2715748)
I'm curious, what are some of the complexities involved in a timekeeping system?
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bane on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:53PM (#2716978)
In this case, one of the issues was that worker's were incensed over biometric scanners proposed for the system intended to fight pervasive time reporting fraud.

http://www.citylimits.org/news/article_print.cfm?article_id=... (article from 2005 when it was only 6x over budget)

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by ams6110 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:37PM (#2715823)
Things like varying overtime rates depending on time of day, accumulated hours, whether it's a holiday, different rates for depending on specific work assignments, etc. It's not as simple as a flat rate x number of hours. But it's nothing that hasn't been done before, either.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by smokeyj on Thursday June 30, 2011 @06:36PM (#2715998)
At first I was like, "wow this would take me five minutes to program". Now it's looking like a solid 20 minutes.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by rluhar on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:38PM (#2716409)
Agreed. You also have to think about who can approve the hours booked. So you would need to have some sort of hook into the HR / Org database which determines each users entitlements. It gets very very complicated! Technically, the problem is nothing new. The difficulty lies in designing the system and getting it to work correctly with an organizations existing business processes and systems.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by blatherard on Thursday June 30, 2011 @07:00PM (#2716079)
You should also account for scale.

The City of New York employs about a quarter of a million people, which is around the same size as General Electric or GM, worldwide, performing a wide range of job functions.

Also: the particular system under development included hand scanners, so you should include developing for that.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by mavelikara on Thursday June 30, 2011 @07:04PM (#2716100)
For those wondering how the project could have cost so much, here are some of the annual salaries that were paid out:

  Job Title                     Annual Salary
  -------------------------------------------
  Specialist, Level 4A          $676, 031
  Project Manager, Level 4      $661, 628
  Project Manager, Level 3      $632, 653
  Project Manager, Level 3D     $601, 286
From http://www.nydailynews.com/topics/Gerard+Denault/photos
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by calloc on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:38PM (#2716406)
Those job titles are set by the government and specify what pay is going to be. My job title at my current company is Computer Analyst, yet I am a computer programmer. The gov't contract we have mandates that specific title.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by lobster_johnson on Friday July 01, 2011 @09:08AM (#2718130)
And yet what programmer, or project manager, has a salary of $676,031? Those are top-level manager salaries.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by ap22213 on Friday July 01, 2011 @11:35AM (#2718747)
Yeah, those look like outrageous salaries. But, to be fair, I doubt they are salaries. They're probably derived from hourly consultant rates of around $250 / hour.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by bradleyland on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:29PM (#2715626)
It would seem that way, but this is municipal government, so there is likely local code (law) that imposes requirements that will boggle your mind and are likely unique to NYC. Take any trivial software task, target municipalities as your customer, and you'd better triple your budgets.

Municipal governments are a large portion of our business, so I'm intimately familiar with the challenges. What's unfortunate is that it's infrequently the fault of the individuals running the municipality. We meet a lot of really great people out in the field. It's just that they're doing their job with one hand tied behind their back. They have to operate within a framework that is (mis)guided by public interest.

Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by kmfrk on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:27PM (#2715612)
This is fairly common; a decent, working solution already exists, but (the) government wants to do its own instead of adopting the existing system, and the bills begin piling up.
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by emehrkay on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:13PM (#2716319)
I could write one this weekend for only 3 million dollars. Somebody get me bloomberg's info
Re:NYC mayor demands $600M refund on software project by patio11 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:47PM (#2716446)
Do payroll slips issued by the system to part-time workers have the option to translate the statement of worker's rights mandated by NY city law on the back of the slip into Mandarin Chinese? No? "Did you even read the bid document? It was right there on page 487 where it said 'The system must be fully compliant with NYC labor law.'"

There are literally a hundred thousand requirements like that one.