News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EV Range Breakthrough as New Aluminum-Ion Battery Charges... by esperen on Friday May 14, 2021 @11:02AM (#27155028)
mAh g-1 is very simple to understand. It is common notation to put a -1 exponent to indicate division.

Work to calculate the energy density comparison when that isn't even the point of the article. Everyone can look up the energey density and theoretical of a li-ion battery: 100-265 Wh/kg. There is absolutely no need to calculate anything.

Focus on the substance of the article. 60x faster charging rate as compared to Lithium-ion and make a comment regarding that. Otherwise your comments are as pointless as my reply to it.

Re:EV Range Breakthrough as New Aluminum-Ion Battery Charges... by omgwtfbyobbq on Friday May 14, 2021 @12:40PM (#27156293)
The problem with the article is that it lacks substance. As an example, it mentions that al-ion has intrinsic advantages and disadvantages compared to li-ion, but it only talks about advantages.

Aluminum-ion technology has intrinsic advantages and disadvantages over the preeminent lithium-ion battery technology being used in almost every EV today.

What do calendar and cycle life in different conditions look like? How do weight/volume per unit power/energy compare with existing li-ion cells? And so on...

It seems like they found a way to improve the energy density of the al-ion cells mentioned in this Stanford news story.

https://news.stanford.edu/2015/04/06/aluminum-ion-battery-03...

But without more detailed specs, it's impossible to compare their cells to existing li-ion cells outside of the specific examples they are using.

Re:EV Range Breakthrough as New Aluminum-Ion Battery Charges... by labawi on Friday May 14, 2021 @05:20PM (#27159840)
My laptop battery charges under a minute, but that doesn't make it any good.

If you have no issues with the units / expressions used in the article, could you please explain what is the power and energy density from this quote:

> Stanford’s natural graphite aluminum-ion technology delivers 68.7 Watt-hours per kilogram and 41.2 Watts per kilogram, while its graphite-foam bumps up to 3000Wh/kg.

> The GMG-UQ battery heaves that forward to between 150 and 160Wh/kg and 7000Wh/kg.

Re:EV Range Breakthrough as New Aluminum-Ion Battery Charges... by qayxc on Friday May 14, 2021 @12:48PM (#27156427)
> It is common notation to put a -1 exponent to indicate division.

I have zero issues with using negative exponents, what I do take issue with is writing "g-1" in an online publication. You either use proper HTML to write an exponent as an exponent, or you use division.

"g-1" is not a a unit, it spells out "gram - 1", which makes no sense at all and there's zero excuse for not even using the commonly accepted crutch "g^-1".