Re:Google+ is competing with LinkedIn and Microsoft, not Fac...
by billybob on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:26PM
(#2715605)
I agree that Circles seems like a great idea. I've always hated that in Facebook, everyone is either my friend or not. It's awkward to have to decide if someone is a friend. You either end up with lots of non-friend friends, or you have to start explicitly telling people "no, we are merely acquaintances. Let's be perfectly clear: I am not your friend."
That's awkward, and in real life, you don't have to do it. So you shouldn't have to do it online.
It's much better if I can group people into whatever circles make sense to me, and they can do the same to me. Nobody should get to see how I group people. It's my mental model of the world, not theirs.
Re:Google+ is competing with LinkedIn and Microsoft, not Fac...
by joebadmo on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:34PM
(#2715645)
It doesn't quite map to any known mental model, though, because when someone replies to your post, it's broadcast to your friends instead of their friends. I think this is potentially extremely confusing and weird. I think "Places" are a better metaphor: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2714333
Re:Google+ is competing with LinkedIn and Microsoft, not Fac...
by sapper2 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:19PM
(#2715581)
But that increases the risk that you share information by mistake (either yours or google+) with the wrong group.
That is why people (should) have different email for private and business use. That is why I have facebook and linkedin accounts. It is very unlikely that I will upload my party pics to linkedin ;)
Re:Google+ is competing with LinkedIn and Microsoft, not Fac...
by cheald on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:23PM
(#2715596)
Certainly, that's understandable. People will still be stupid, but at that point, it's a people problem rather than a tech problem .It may just be that I grok it, but I don't forsee any problem at all separating the kinds of content I post.
I have Circles set up for groups of work colleagues, professional contacts, family, and friends who I like to share fart jokes with. In each case, I can interact with those people in a manner appropriate to the nature of my relationship with them. That solves the Facebook problem for me (I didn't use it because I nearly never had anything I wanted to share with everyone I knew in the world), and also creates an environment where I can have fun with my friends and be professional with my colleagues without compromising either group.
I really like it.