News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bezos Calculator by dragonwriter on Thursday May 13, 2021 @02:30PM (#27145547)
> Capital gains are not cash income, and to treat them the same is to fundamentally misunderstand money.

Realized capital gains are, in point of fact, cash income.

They aren’t, for most people (though this is less true weighted by dollars of realized gains) part of a stream of regularly recurring income the way salary from a fixed-schedule, fixed-pay job is. And there are fairness implications to not accommodating that in a progressive income tax system. But a lower set of brackets for fains from assets held 366 (or 367) days isn’t a really good way of handling the real differences.

Allowing distributing recognition of income over time (both advance and deferred) is sensible to handle both long-term capital gains and chunky income from other sources (e.g., the typical pattern of royalties vs. work for writing books) fairly, and adjusting the basis value of capital items on which gains are calculated for inflation is sensible as well.

There’s no good reason for a lower general tax rate for long term capital gains instead of those measures; compared to fair treatment, it (among capital gains payers, not even considering the relations to other income) benefits those with large capital holdings and recurring gains, and adversely impacts those whose gains come from occasional sale of really-long-held assets, so that to tune it to a level that feels “fair” for middle-class capital gains it has to be excessively generous to hypercapitalists.

Unrealized gains aren’t cash income, sure, they are just reasonably anticipated future cash income (which is a kind of thing we sometimes require anticipatory payment against expected tax liability on in other contexts.)

Re:Bezos Calculator by sneak on Thursday May 13, 2021 @04:19PM (#27146880)
> Realized capital gains are, in point of fact, cash income.

That's not what TFA is tracking.

Re:Bezos Calculator by dragonwriter on Thursday May 13, 2021 @04:33PM (#27147061)
> > Realized capital gains are, in point of fact, cash income.

> That's not what TFA is tracking

Congratulations on reading the first sentence of the post. Perhaps at some point later there was discussion of how unrealized gains relate back to the cash income that is realized gains and how that is relevant to taxation, for which discussion of realized gains was preparatory, rather than the first sentence being the whole of the response.

Re:Bezos Calculator by sneak on Thursday May 13, 2021 @05:02PM (#27147430)
I read it in full before replying. It starts straight off off-topic, though.

Amazon is Bezos' life's work. It strikes me as silly to frame his capital gains in the context of the taxes he'll owe when he "eventually sells", like a homeowner who moves or a daytrader who closes out a position.

Re:Bezos Calculator by dragonwriter on Thursday May 13, 2021 @05:08PM (#27147492)
> It strikes me as silly to frame his capital gains in the context of the taxes he'll owe when he "eventually sells", like a homeowner who moves or a daytrader who closes out a position.

Sure, its silly if you’re Jeff Bezos discussing its general role in your life.

For anybody else, or even Bezos himself discussing tax policy, that it js his life’s work is no more relevant to tax policy than that other people’s “life’s work” goes into their creative endeavours whose proceeds aren’t taxed at favorable LTCG rates, or that still other’s “life’s work” is done in thr context of teaching, or construction, or any number of other endeavours done mostly through positions that are paid and taxed as wage labor.