News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by rvkennedy on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:43AM (#2713758)
First thought: the Swedes are doing well! Why is 60% of GDP the target? What does this do?
Re:Government Debt (chart) by guelo on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:50AM (#2713990)
The Swedes just used basic Keynesian economics to fight the recession. They went into the recession with the budget in good shape, unlike the Bush approach of deficits and expensive wars. Then when the recession hit their huge welfare system kicked into high gear plus they added a stimulus of tax cuts and infrastructure projects, unlike the Obama approach of no net stimulus when you add the smallish federal stimulus minus state government cuts.

Also their central bank cranked up QE higher than our Fed, and their politicians didn't run around freaking out about "debasing the currency".

Read about it here http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/five-economic...

Re:Government Debt (chart) by pragmatic on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:24AM (#2714129)
Fantastic point.

I don't think enough people understand that Keynes doens't work if you are running a massive deficit all the time. In good times you _need_ to be solvent so that in bad times, extra gov't spending will actually have an effect.

The US is not able to implement Keynesian policies b/c we borrow and spend constantly.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by watchandwait on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:44AM (#2714479)
None of the American "Keynesians" calling for deficit spending today called for a balanced budget 5 years ago during the boom. I'd argue there are no true Keynesians, just politicians looking for an excuse to continue spending.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by guelo on Thursday June 30, 2011 @12:05PM (#2714561)
If you didn't hear liberals complaining that we couldn't afford the wars and Bush's tax cuts then you weren't paying attention.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by beatpanda on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:48AM (#2714232)
In fairness, that wasn't the "Obama approach". The stimulus was whittled down by the Congress.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by CaptainZapp on Thursday June 30, 2011 @08:45AM (#2713764)
From the explanation :

The chart below shows OECD calculations of what it would take governments to reduce gross debt to 60% of GDP by 2026. This is around the level considered healthy and is also the ratio set by the widely ignored Maastricht agreement, which is meant to govern debt in the European Union. It is not pretty.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by mixmax on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:14AM (#2713861)
The Swedes had a serious financial crisis in the mid 90's and learnt their lesson. They've been running a sound fiscal policy ever since.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by arethuza on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:24AM (#2713889)
Maybe the Greeks should invite the Swedes to run their country for them!
Re:Government Debt (chart) by bh42222 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:33AM (#2714177)
Well.... the EU is sort of, kind of, like that. The treaty of Maastricht, EU regulations superseding national regulations, it's all supposed bring rich north western European style government to the poorer more chaotic south and east parts of Europe.

<sarcasm>And it's working out great!</sarcasm>

Re:Government Debt (chart) by henrikschroder on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:37AM (#2714191)
That wouldn't help, the underlying problem is that the general tax morale is much lower in Greece compared to Sweden.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by chrismealy on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:47AM (#2714229)
60% is the magic number from Reinhart and Rogoff. Their work is flawed because they failed to distinguish between public debt borrowed in a country's own currency versus other currencies.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by pragmatic on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:33AM (#2714179)
Can any Swedes confirm/deny this summary of the pension plan:

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2000/06/pension-ref...

"Partial privatization. Workers can invest 2.5 percentage points of the 18.5 percent of their income that they must set aside for retirement. Soon workers will be able to choose the pension fund into which the funds will go."

Any talk of even partial privatization in the US gets the old folks quite worked up. Political scare tactics and such. Plus a healthy (and not unwarranted) distrust of Wall Street that would love to get it's filthy paws on _even more_ retirement money.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by CaptainZapp on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:02AM (#2714299)
I can't speak for Sweden, but for Switzerland where your pension rests on three pillars. Two of them mandatory and one where you're free to invest, but receive tax benefits if you do:

Pillar 1 is called AHV (AVS in French). This is the responsibility of the federal government and there are no plans to privatize this; ever. Since there is a maximum payout, which is quite low it has a certain wealth redistribution component. That is: When you make a lot of money you pay a percentage into the fund, which is a percentage of your earnings. So, a person making a lot of money pays more into it, but since the payout is capped at a fairly low level, he may get the same benefits as somebody who earned much less and thus payed much less into the fund

Pillar 2 is the actual pension plan, which is mandatory. Every company must insure their employees and big companies run their own schemes. While those funds are privately run, there are strong restrictions in place how they can invest the money of their insureds. The difference to the AHV is that the payout depends on the amount you payed in over your lifetime as a worker. Payout is based on a formula and the age of retirement can be dependent on the insurer. Employees don't have a choice about which pension plan they have and there are differences in quality. I could imagine that the system in Sweden is comparable (private, but very restricted in how they invest) but must admit that I'm assuming here.

Pillar 3, incidentally called pillar 3 (3. Säule) is not mandatory. You can pay a maximum yearly amount into a fund, a bank account or to an insurer (~ 7500$ if employed ~ 38000$ if you're not part of a pillar 2 pension plan) and this amount is fully tax deductible. The string is that you can only get it out when you turn 60. There are ways to get the money out before that. Either when you invest in a house, or apartment or when you leave the country for good. Same goes for the pillar 2 assets accumulated.

There's no such thing that a company can legally pull an Enron and invest the assets of their employees into their own company.

I know that the Swiss system is considered excellent. The dutch system is considered even better, but I have no expertise to discuss it.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by henrikschroder on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:29AM (#2714421)
It's been like that for almost ten years now I think. You can read a little bit about it here, "Premium Pension" is the type you want:

http://pensionsmyndigheten.se/AboutYourPensions_en.html

Basically, part of the blob of income tax you pay on your salary is a "pension fee". When you retire around the age of 65, your final pension depends partially on how much you've paid in pension fees in total while working. But you don't set aside that money, instead the pensions fees people pay now are used to pay pensions for retired citizens, and future pensions will be financed by the future workforce.

But then you have the "Premium pension" which does allow you to set aside part of your pension fee and invest into private funds. Generally the systems is a failure, most people don't care about choosing funds, so they automatically end up in a government run generally mediocre fund. A small percentage are investing soundly and successfully, a larger percentage are investing badly, and most people get screwed by high commission fees of the various funds.

On top of these systems there are of course ways to save additional money for your retirement, there are some tax benefits, and you are free to invest pretty much however you want.

But yes, it is interesting that we have more privatization than the US in this, it doesn't happen very often. :-)

Re:Government Debt (chart) by larrik on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:05AM (#2714048)
Sweden also seems to offer free college tuition, even for advanced degrees. Coincidence? Maybe...

It's too bad you apparently can go to jail there if you have sex with someone, they regret it, and then a politician wants to make that a crime afterwards.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by Vivtek on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:45AM (#2714220)
... and you refuse to comply with requests for investigation and flee the country.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by marshray on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:59AM (#2714283)
If you're referring to Assange, as I understand it he'd already spoken with prosecutors once and they explicitly declined to prosecute. He was not under any order not to leave, so he didn't "flee the country". I would probably decline to return to some country for my transparently politically-motivated prosecution too.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by pragmatic on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:28AM (#2714144)
The Swedes are just ahead of the curve.

They crashed in the 90's:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Sweden

Then they reformed and recovered.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by icegreentea on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:20AM (#2714117)
60% is the something like the global average.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by lucasjung on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:01AM (#2713822)
My understanding is that Sweden has drawn a significant portion of its revenues from North Sea oil, but that they are anticipating significant declines in production (and therefore revenue). They are preparing for this by grdually restructuring (read: cutting) government services and benefits to fit their anticipated revenue, with the added benefit that doing so in advance allows them to build up a decent nest-egg. In other words, they are doing something incredibly rare for a government: budgeting in a responsible and rational manner.
Re:Government Debt (chart) by Tuna-Fish on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:57AM (#2714016)
Sweden has practically no oil production at all, and never had any. The Scandinavian country with large oil reserves is Norway.

What you are talking about doesn't even describe Norway properly -- they have largely not spent the revenue they got from oil. Instead, it has been collected into a sovereign wealth fund. At present, the fund holds some $100 000 for every Norwegian. Future decline of oil profits will be covered by the investment income from the fund. There hasn't been any cutting of government services to fit revenues -- there hasn't been any need to.

Sweden, like the other Scandinavian countries, has held a responsible and rational budget for most of it's existence as a democratic country. So while it might be incredibly rare for governments worldwide, for some reason it seems that the Scandinavians can make the idea of a well-run welfare state work. I have yet to figure out why they can do it and most of the rest of the world seemingly can't.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by henrikschroder on Thursday June 30, 2011 @11:34AM (#2714438)
> I have yet to figure out why they can do it and most of the rest of the world seemingly can't.

It helps a lot to have a small country with an ethnically homogenous population, extremely low corruption, high tax morale, and high public trust of government offices and institutions.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by bh42222 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @01:35PM (#2714954)
It helps a lot to have a small country

Maybe, or a big but dictatorial country like China.

an ethnically homogenous population

Care to elaborate? Would you consider countries such as Switzerland, Canada, Taiwan, and Singapore ethnically homogeneous?

extremely low corruption, high tax morale, and high public trust of government offices and institutions.

Chicken and egg problem - High tax compliance and trust in government come from having a reasonable tax rate from which you get a lot of effective government services. Low corruption is a pre-requisite for trust in government institutions.

I bet what also helps is not having a culture of cousin marriage, that seems to create a culture where is much more difficult to have any kind of trust with people outside of your clan.

I think the modern well functioning democracy is to a very large degree a result of complex game theory.

You don't have to look back much more the 2 centuries, to see thousands of years of European history that's full of corruption, lawlessness, crushing tax rates, all the typical modern day 3rd world problems and then some.

If just being Swedish led to modern Sweden, Swedish history would be a lot less interesting. For one, it would almost certainly be entirely Viking free.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by furyg3 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:54AM (#2714259)
The Norway situation you describe is correct.

Normally an influx of wealth from oil (or other natural resources, even humanitarian aid) will suppress the country's abilities to be competitive in manufacturing or other (non-oil) sectors. It's often called a "Resource Curse" or "Dutch Disease".

Avoiding the curse requires not to spending the oil money directly... and instead to invest it and spend only the interest.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by RuadhanMc on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:52AM (#2714003)
Pretty sure that you are thinking of Norway. Sweden doesn't do oil in any serious way. Sweden is trying to be oil-free.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Making_Sweden_an_Oil-Free_Socie...

According to Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Sweden) Sweden's main industries are: telecommunications equipment, wood pulp and paper products, motor vehicles, pharmaceutical products, iron and steel.

That's quite a nice spread.

Re:Government Debt (chart) by bh42222 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @10:36AM (#2714189)
Sweden's main industries are: telecommunications equipment, wood pulp and paper products, motor vehicles, pharmaceutical products, iron and steel.

And ABBA. (I'm only half joking the royalties on their music equal quite a few Volvos.)

Re:Government Debt (chart) by bh42222 on Thursday June 30, 2011 @01:39PM (#2714973)
Replying to myself because someone on the Internet is wrong!

... between 1974 and 1982,they earned nearly twice the GNP of Sweden

From: http://www.artistfacts.com/detail.php?id=322

Re:Government Debt (chart) by RuadhanMc on Thursday June 30, 2011 @03:06PM (#2715326)
That is pretty staggering...

This too: "When ABBA was active, only the Volvo car company made more money in Sweden.".

Re:Government Debt (chart) by mseebach on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:15AM (#2713863)
I couldn't find anything definitive on Google, but I don't think Sweden has that much oil, and if they do, it's not in the North Sea (which isn't bordering Sweden). (You might have meant to refer to Norway or Denmark which fits your description quite well)
Re:Government Debt (chart) by arethuza on Thursday June 30, 2011 @09:13AM (#2713854)
I didn't know that Sweden had any oil - unlike Norway next door that is practically floating on the stuff.