News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is a Nuclear Microreactor? by godelski on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:56PM (#27136185)
The shutdown mechanisms are specifically about the containment of heat. The problem is generally about a reaction not being shut off. Gen 3 and beyond reactors, which includes these, don't have these problem at all. But neither do Gen 2's, anymore.

But if we're going to talk about the 3 accidents, we should note that they are quite different.

Chernobyl was a positive pressure reactor. Only the Russians were ~~dumb~~interested in building these. Everyone else was afraid because their ability to explode and instead chose reactors that couldn't explode. The accident happened not just because of this, but because the xenon spike and not a great understanding of the science.

TMI had a bunch of things go on at once. Relief valve stuck open but indicating close. Not enough water during SCRAM. Turning off ECCS due to bad indications. Then the hydrogen explosion. Resulting in about a dental x-ray's worth of radiation for a limited number of people. We now have hydrogen absorbers and have upgraded reactors to ensure these events don't happen again. [0] (this channel also talks about all the events).

Fukushima was caused by the largest earthquake and tsunami ever recorded in the region (so lower bounding to 1k year event) and one of the largest ever recorded anywhere. The reactors were designed to withstand quakes and tsunamis. The tsunami and earthquake were much larger than anyone expected to ever happen in the region. Reactor got destroyed and it is hard to track where all the material went, which is why they have the region closed down (background radiation levels aren't so bad, but you don't want to risk consumption of reactor material. Similar to why the surrounding area of Chernobyl is closed).

The reason I bring all these up is because we should note that even Gen 2 reactors have been retrofitted with improvements from these events, and have been this way for a long time.

[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0SCf0rxX4E

Re:What Is a Nuclear Microreactor? by korethr on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:14PM (#27136363)
> The shutdown mechanisms are specifically about the containment of heat. The problem is generally about a reaction not being shut off.

Indeed? I was of the understanding that the shutdown mechanisms were specifically for halting the chain reaction, and largely a solved problem with mature tech, and it was containing the decay heat of Gen 2 designs that was the trickier problem.

I am happy to be wrong about the latter, though perhaps not as happy to be wrong about the former.

Re:What Is a Nuclear Microreactor? by godelski on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:04PM (#27136748)
If the reaction is shut off then heat will decrease, not grow. So like TMI is an example where they thought the reaction was quenched but wasn't actually, due to bad sensors and other sensors not being near one another/easy to compare (this is fixed and obviously sensors have become more reliable since then). The reaction won't start up again without some source. If reactions were easy to maintain we would have had nuclear reactors long before the 50's.