Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by Fezzik on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:25AM
(#27126916)
Thank goodness for obsessive Icelandic historians! Another one, Snorri Sturluson, is responsible for writing down much of the Norse mythology that we know of today. He is cited a bunch in The Norse Myths (a great book, in my humble opinion. Though I may be biased based on my fealty to my Norwegian heritage).
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by krapp on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:00AM
(#27128560)
Unfortunately, Snorri Sturlson was no historian. What he wrote down was a Christian reframing of Norse mythology as political and religious propaganda, leaving almost no trace of the original, native mythology for the historical record.
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by goto11 on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:01AM
(#27129814)
Is that fair? Since we have no pre-Christian sources to compare to, it is hard to say how fairly Snorri represent the tradition. (Obviously the bit where he explains the Norse gods as descendants of princes of Troy is of dubious authenticity.)
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by krapp on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:53PM
(#27137166)
That's exactly the problem - we don't know. There are many elements that look suspiciously like attempts at Christian syncretism, like Baldr's death and resurrection, and Ragnarok (a fiery apocalypse survived by one man and one woman, where one God reigns supreme.)
All we know is that there was Christian influence, because Snorri was a Christian, living and writing in Christianized Scandinavia to a Christian audience.
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by UserForANow on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:47AM
(#27128161)
Icelandic sagas are fun reading and great literature. You get to peek into another time period where law and morals where quite different and savage hero's rage with both sharp tongues and swords
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by QuesnayJr on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:41AM
(#27128450)
Njal's Saga deserves to be regarded as a classic of world literature. It's full of compelling scenes, and dramatizes the how the desire for revenge just leads to an endless cycle of revenge.
Re:An obsessive scholar who rescued Iceland’s ancient litera...
by wccrawford on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:59AM
(#27129792)
I think when bad things have good qualities, people still admire those good qualities while being wary of the bad ones.
In this case, obsessive means that they put in effort that others wouldn't. It could lead to ruin, or it could reward them greatly.
The bad part is the lack of detachment that lets them think about it logically, instead of being forced to just do it. Reward or ruin, they're going to do it either way.
Edit: spelling
All we know is that there was Christian influence, because Snorri was a Christian, living and writing in Christianized Scandinavia to a Christian audience.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27121281
In this case, obsessive means that they put in effort that others wouldn't. It could lead to ruin, or it could reward them greatly.
The bad part is the lack of detachment that lets them think about it logically, instead of being forced to just do it. Reward or ruin, they're going to do it either way.