Re:We’ll stop selling our Code Editor app for iOS soon
by nicoburns on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @06:05PM
(#27124175)
I think there's reasonable argument to be made that smartphones are important enough that they should not ve like consoles, and should be forced to be more open. I guess a similar argument to that used to justify regulating utlities.
Re:We’ll stop selling our Code Editor app for iOS soon
by dwaite on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @02:00AM
(#27127109)
The problem is that there are a mix of technical and non-technical restrictions in order to keep end users from shooting themselves in the foot.
It is likely a "careful what you wish for" with regulating the platforms like utilities, because they would likely regulate much farther down - the governments would become an additional party setting app store policy to a much greater degree than we see today.
I think a lot of iOS's limitations come from a philosophical stance Apple took at the start of the (iOS) App Store -- iPhones and iPads should be treated like consoles, not general purpose computing platforms. Despite them marketing the iPad Pro as if it's a full-bore computer replacement -- and to be fair, there are a lot of use cases where it really can be (e.g., office worker, photographer, writer[1], even video/audio editor -- on an OS level, they've stubbornly stuck with the "Mac = computer, iPad = console" approach[2] and I don't think they're going to change it unless forced.
[1] With certain limitations. I can use an iPad well enough for my fiction and non-fiction, but not for my technical writing.
[2] The "Mac = computer" part of that is why I disagree with the prevailing opinion on HN about how Apple will "inevitably" lock down the Mac to the same degree they have the iPad; I think they continue to see them as fundamentally different classes of products, even as that distinction grows ever more arbitrary.