Re:The Time Everyone “Corrected” the World’s Smartest Woman ...
by haberman on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:54AM
(#27114351)
TL;DR: I was wrong (but I did understand the distinction you are drawing)
I'm aware that there is a difference between devious Monty and dumb Monty. The question I was trying to answer is whether this difference affects the actual outcome of the game, or the choice you should make.
I ran a Monte Carlo simulation to test my analysis, and this proved that my previous analysis was in error. If Monty doesn't know to avoid the door with the car, then it makes no difference statistically speaking whether the player switches or not after Monty reveals a goat.
If the rules are such that you win when (dumb) Monty picks the car, then your overall chances are now 2/3 instead of 1/3, since you effectively get two guesses (your guess and Monty's guess). But it makes no difference whether you switch after Monty picks a goat.
On the other hand, if (dumb) Monty choosing the car results in either (1) you losing or (2) a reshuffle and redo, then your overall chances are only 1/3. In this case, it also makes no difference whether you switch after Monty's guess.
I'm aware that there is a difference between devious Monty and dumb Monty. The question I was trying to answer is whether this difference affects the actual outcome of the game, or the choice you should make.
I ran a Monte Carlo simulation to test my analysis, and this proved that my previous analysis was in error. If Monty doesn't know to avoid the door with the car, then it makes no difference statistically speaking whether the player switches or not after Monty reveals a goat.
If the rules are such that you win when (dumb) Monty picks the car, then your overall chances are now 2/3 instead of 1/3, since you effectively get two guesses (your guess and Monty's guess). But it makes no difference whether you switch after Monty picks a goat.
On the other hand, if (dumb) Monty choosing the car results in either (1) you losing or (2) a reshuffle and redo, then your overall chances are only 1/3. In this case, it also makes no difference whether you switch after Monty's guess.