News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:59PM (#27113314)
“Let them…”, “Make them…”, etc. I get the impression the author thinks “neurotypicals” should handle autistic people like pets or slaves.

I think the author confuses a literal spectrum of behaviors with their clinical labels. The DSM is a diagnostic tool, not a catalog of identity labels.

Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Monday May 10, 2021 @10:20PM (#27113478)
That's kind of a hurtful thing to say about the author who I'm sure has good intentions. People who reach to medical literature for a sense of identity it's symptomatic of a deeper issue that deserves a certain degree of compassion, although in the case of aspergers syndrome I don't people would embrace it as an identity if they knew what it used to be called. Elon Musk was hiding it this whole time.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:29AM (#27114538)
I think it’s “hurtful,” or at least ignorant, to imply that people with autism spectrum disorders need to be allowed or made to do anything. Good intentions aside, bad information doesn’t help anyone.

I was diagnosed as “borderline autistic” as a child and was later told I showed signs of Asperger’s. I’ve never thought of it as an identity, just a glitch in my personality. It’s a disorder in the sense that it sometimes interferes with how I deal with people and situations, but I wouldn’t call it disabling. I’ve known people with far worse symptoms.

The author claims “ Autistic individuals don’t have any difficulty communicating with another autistic.” That makes me wonder how much the author knows about severe autism. I agree with the previous posts about the author presenting a Hollywood version, equating often debilitating autism spectrum disorders with “Rain Main” superintelligence or idiot savants. It should be obvious that Elon Musk functions at a very high level. I don’t think he makes a good poster boy for autistics.

Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:12AM (#27117640)
And how did people like the author treat you as a child?
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:43PM (#27120302)
I don’t know what the author is like, so I can’t say. I’ve shared all I’m willing to share about my life. Like everyone else, I’ve had to deal with my personality quirks. Like everyone else I’ve had to adapt and learn how to get along in the world. I don’t identify myself with diagnostic names attached to symptoms.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @05:25PM (#27123724)
But that's exactly what makes you different, according to the medical literature. Normal people deal with their personality quirks without thinking about it. That's what makes them normal. With you, it required an act of willpower. Just like, if normal people wanted to innovate, it would require an act of willpower on their part; whereas for you, you've been doing it your whole life.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:45AM (#27126681)
But I'm not different in that respect. Everyone has different abilities. No individual is "normal," that's a statistical artifact. Everyone has personality quirks, whether they are aware of them or not, and has to adapt their personality constantly. I don't think of my quirks and shortcomings as disabilities or medical issues, anymore than I would think a left-handed person has a disorder, even if they aren't (statistically) normal.

That's not to say everyone who suffers from autism or any other physical or mental disorder can just will themselves to overcome it, or adapt -- some people have seriously debilitating problems. I have been around severely autistic children and I can't compare my experience to theirs, like I can't compare my inability to dance to someone in a wheelchair.

"Normal" people innovate all the time, I imagine that takes an act of willpower for everyone. I haven't been innovating my whole life, just dealing with it one day at a time like everyone else does.

Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:21PM (#27134134)
Not being able to dance is another thing the medical literature says people in your position can't do, along with orthography. Have you considered that willpower is uncommon in people, due to how willfulness is traditionally punished and killed by centuries of war? That seems to be why autistic people usually don't change and why neurotypical people usually don't innovate.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:57PM (#27134438)
I think we’re going out into the weeds. I’m not looking for explanations or excuses. I can’t dance because I never cared to learn, not because I’m physically unable to do it. I have played sports and done other activities that require coordination. I got top score on my verbal/written SAT so orthography isn’t a problem for me either. The mistake would be saying to myself “I have Asperger’s so I can’t dance or write,” which would just be making excuses.

I don’t think willpower is uncommon, that’s not my experience. I don’t know what war has to do with it — consider the willpower required to participate in that kind of conflict, or survive it. What evidence do you have that “autistic people don’t change” and “neurotypical people don’t innovate?”

To pump up the meme that people diagnosed with autism or Asperger’s are geniuses stuck in a shell it’s become popular to retroactively diagnose historical figures. Da Vinci? Autistic. Lincoln? Aspeger’s. Elon Musk — clearly a successful and high-functioning person, may have some Asperger’s symptoms, or he may just say that because it’s cool and lets him off the hook for acting like a jerk sometimes. I don’t know. I don’t think every “innovator” is an undiagnosed autistic. It seems obvious that most innovation must come from neurotypicals because they are, by definition (in the frame of this discussion anyway) the large majority.

Autistic people do change. Children often grow out of autistic behavior at least partially. Not always, some never improve, but many do.

There’s no line between autistic/Asperger’s and neurotypical, those are phony boxes that insufficiently describe a literal spectrum of behaviors and personality gifts and deficits. At the extremes of the spectrum you find people who are seriously impaired, but along most of the curve people function well enough.

Think about physical abilities. Most people can walk and get around and do day-to-day things. Some can play basketball a few can play like Michael Jordan. Some struggle to stand up, a few can’t get out of bed. There’s a range of physical abilities and everyone is born with some gifts and some deficits. I think it’s the same with mental abilities and personality.

Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:43PM (#27134945)
If you're comparing dancing to sports and orthography to written SAT, then I get the impression you might not even understand what either of things really mean. The medical literature says you're literally incapable of doing it, regardless of how hard you try. Now, that doesn't say anything about your value as person. No one cares if you're bad at writing wedding cards. In fact the sorts of people who are good at those things would probably feel excited to have the opportunity to feel useful if you were to delegate the task to them.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:59PM (#27137953)
No medical literature says I or anyone else is incapable of dancing or orthography. A statistical average of autistics showing this or that impairment over a large sample says nothing about individuals. You should read the diagnostic criteria for autism spectrum disorders, which includes what is called Asperger’s. Here it is in case you don’t have the DSM-5 handy: https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/hcp-dsm.html

A person who can’t dance or isn’t comfortable talking to strangers isn’t necessarily “on the spectrum,” and a person diagnosed with ASD isn’t “literally incapable” of doing those things.

Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by jart on Friday May 14, 2021 @04:47PM (#27159505)
I was going off the primary materials. It's pretty clear that you won't believe that being diagnosed with a disability (well, according to ada, or whichever word you feel most appropriate) means you can't dance and write wedding cards the same way other people do. Have you considered simply challenging the definition? Instead of all this big picture epistemology? You can change the culture so that dance for example includes that thing kraftwerk does. Then no one can laugh because the perception of what it means to be a dancer became more inclusive.
Re:Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotyp... by gregjor on Saturday May 15, 2021 @01:19PM (#27167042)
If I felt disabled or excluded I would take dance lessons or learn calligraphy, like “other” people do. I’m not incapable, just not interested. That isn’t a medical condition. I’m not interested in quixotic attempts to change the culture.

A diagnosis of something so vague and variable as ASD doesn’t imply specific disabilities, or an inability to adapt and overcome. It’s an artificial label, not an identity.