I am not so sure of that. Particularly in rural states, companies like Sears-Roebuck were the prime source of all sorts of amenities of basic life, from phonographs to sewing machines. Sure, it took longer, but the prices were a lot better than general stores. And the selection was amazing. You could buy anything up to and including a new house! (Some assembly required.)
Trying to manage that across the country is an ugly proposition! At least the EU has chosen a single VAT (even if it is outrageous! :).
The claim that determining the applicable sales tax for any given shipping/billing address is difficult is complete BS.
One small example: many jurisdictions tax different categories of items at different rates. This means that you'd have to start off by knowing those rules and categorizing everything accordingly. After that, you have tons of edge cases to work out, e.g., what happens if I group two different categories of items into a special package? What percentage of the package is taxed at what rate? Or, what if different states categorize the same item in different ways? Or, what happens when you provide a service to sellers and then need the sellers to accurately provide all of this categorization for every jurisdiction?
Of all companies, Amazon probably has the best chance of getting this all figured out if they really had to. However, calling it difficult is by no means BS.
I'm not arguing on the rights/wrongs of this discussion, but this is what it really comes down to.
The problem is the hangup with the commerce clause. Catalog companies didn't threaten to make a significant % of all sales into postal sales, the internet does. I'd hope that we could find a way to straighten things out where the state can still assess the sales tax the way it's written legally without bringing all of these other issues about affiliates into it.
I don't really see where states can go on this, the current strategy seems to be "try and force congressional or SC action", good luck with that. Maybe they just fold on sales tax altogether and shift that burden to income tax.