They talk about investing, so 401k is a likely factor. Let’s break this down assuming you are right and the make $200k now: $200k total comp Less $19.5k x2 401k Less 30% taxes $112.7 take home $9.4k per month Less 3k apartment Less $1k cars Less $300 car ins Less $500 health ins Less $300 utilities/internet/etc Leaves ~$4.3k per month before food and other expenses.
They clearly do not have enough for a 2 or 3 bedroom apartment, child care, extended parental leave (or one spouse not working temporarily) or much of anything else. Remember, it’s not just housing that’s expensive in the Bay Area, but also food and many other basic services.
The math without a child isn't so bad. Take out $5K for taxes, $3K for rent, $3K for food/utilities/car/etc. If they're lucky to not have other non-discretionary expenses hanging over their heads and are frugal, then yeah, that's $4K/month leftover for spending, savings, etc.
How far does $4K/month go with a child? Well, first, the mom is very likely to face a disruption in income and/or income growth. Second, childcare will be necessary in order to continue bringing in dual income. That could easily run $2K/month. Third, they will have to either remain packed into an "affordable" 1BR apartment, or find more housing at some cost (either money or commute time). Fourth, for many people, the notion of starting a family is an expectation of multiple children.
People can and do make it work, but it's not easy, and at these tight margins any sort of disruption can spell disaster. That's why people who are doing ok without children can still feel like their financial position is too weak to support a family.
Let's see..3x12=36,000
2x90,000 (probably a lot more given it is a starting salary) =$180,000
even after accounting for taxes and other expenses, that is still a lot left over.
Stopped reading after that. They literally just refuted their own thesis.