https://github.com/antonblanchard/microwatt
(Disclaimer: minor contributor)
I really liked PA-RISC. I thought it was a clean ISA with good performance at the time and avoided many of the pitfalls of other implementations. I think HP didn't want to pour lots of money into it to keep it competitive, though, and was happy to bail out for Itanium when it was viable. My big C8000 is a power hungry titan, makes the Quad G5 seem thrifty.
If you look at ARM, particularly the 64-bit version, you'll notice it attempts to squeeze multiple operations into a single 32-bit "instruction". It's still called RISC, but not really "reduced" anymore.
I thought Alpha and ARM were the same with respect to that.
ARM had some fairly nasty to track down XFS file system corruption bugs for quite a while for exactly this reason.
The issue has always been that x86 goes out of its way to generally be more forgiving than the spec.
Is that still true in the present tense? Anybody doing this in 2021? Seems like alpha has been dead for a long time.
(The stroke of genius of the C++11 memory model, compared to the older Java memory model, was that reordering could be treated the same way no matter if performed by processors or compilers).
Alpha’s loosey-goosey memory model makes multithreaded code on SMP systems more challenging. Linux utilizes its Alpha port as a worst-case testbed for data race conditions in its kernel.
SPARC’s register windows are anachronistic and complicate the implementation of CPUs, and I’d guess also make it more difficult to build OoOE cores (so many SPARC chips are in-order, why?)
POWER isn’t so bad though. It’s open enough where you could build your own lower-cost core if you wanted. There’s nothing intrinsic to the ISA that would mandate an expensive chip other than volume constraints.
PA-RISC put up some great numbers back in the day but between the Compaq acquisition (bringing with it Alpha) and Itanium it was chronically under-resourced. They had a great core in the early 90s and basically just incrementally tweaked it until its death.