And if you use ssh-agent, I'm pretty sure it doesn't even send your private key; SSH creates a challenge that your key is used to compute, so even someone eavesdropping with a keylogger on the server won't be able to sniff your password.
If someone steals/owns your personal machine it's actually much easier to gain access to SSH Keys than find your username/password (since an alarming number of people use passwordless ssh keys).
Aside from that though — SSH Keys are probably the biggest barrier to people being able to use and contribute with GitHub.
The barrier to entry of writing software doesn't need to be zero. If a person is going to write code, they should also learn some of the basic tools of the trade.
As a company that makes money from users, it's to GitHub's benefit to make it easy to use their stuff.
You have to log into remote boxes these days and SSH keys are the best way to do that.
(Until 1password gets iTerm2 integration anyway, but the 1password guys don't seem receptive to that idea)
Then I'll amend gregschlom's comment to further say I wish passwordless ssh keys did not exist.
Although I agree that SSH keypairs feel more secure than a username/password, it would make setting up a new machine for development a lot easier than generating a new SSH keypair and adding it to my GitHub (or any other git server) account.
That seems like the best compromise of security and easy of use to me.
As it is, I'm pretty sure this is using standard HTTPS auth with Git, which is not that hard to support.
"Death to the SSH key" applies only to GitHub interactions — getting a list of your repos, for example.
This sounds like a wrong design decision. I wish nobody could log into my github account using anything but my SSH keys.
This is also true of my AWS account: my ec2 instances are protected by SSH keypairs, but if anyone gets my AWS password, he has full control over everything.
I'm not a security expert, but SSH keys feel way safer than passwords, especially with all those recents article showing how easy it can be to bruteforce passwords.