News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on How college became a ruthless competition divorced from learning. Parent comment

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by zhdc1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @03:39AM (#27073355)
> Do everything you can to get accepted into the very best university possible. It's in your power if you work hard and love what you do (for me, it was coding for fun). "Failure" here would mean attending a Top 20 university instead of a Top 10 (while largely reaping the very same benefits).

I agree with the general sentiment, but I think it's worth adding in a couple of caveats.

The demand to get into a top university in the US is so high that even if you meet all of the prerequisites, getting accepted into Tier 1 university relies on an uncomfortable and ever growing amount of luck.

What people forget is that this dynamic is driven by growing demand, and that an increasing number of qualified applicants are being pushed into lower tier universities. While this isn't an absolute guarantee that the overall quality, and marketability, of these universities will increase, this is, in fact, what has been happening.

So yes, work hard, but don't set your goal on achieving a target that is driven as much by random chance as it is by your own effort.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by SadCanadian on Friday May 07, 2021 @03:47AM (#27073413)
Indeed. As many seek out this opportunity and as they all ramp up their efforts, the participants of the tournament will all look similar in skill and aptitude. Thus, the determining factors will increasingly become luck-based. Everyone that wishes to participate should be made aware that they are signing up for a stress-inducing rat race, and that they better double their effort because, at each step, their competitors get more and more capable.

Or, alternatively, seek other options? Maybe try to avoid the race somehow. Since most will be losers, it's probably best to consider alternatives anyway and ask if the prize is even worth winning.

[ Parent | on HN ]