News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Read Mathematics by ColinWright on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @02:42PM (#2706668)
I'm working on something at the moment to try to explain exactly why what you've said here is, to a large extent, simply wrong. It's too long to include here, and it's not yet ready to "publish". You're about two weeks too early.

But let me ask you this. It's easy to cut a square into identical pieces so that all the pieces touch the center point.

In slightly more detail, the pieces are disjoint sets such that their union is the whole square. The pieces are identical except perhaps for details as to the boundaries. To say that they all "touch" the center point means that every non-zero radius disk centered at the center contains some points from each piece.

So now, how many ways can this be done? No, it's not five. And no, it's not six either.

When you start trying to work it out you find that the details matter, and they can't just be covered by a "childish" drawing to illustrate.

Details matter, and some of them are hard.

Yes, most math teaching is atrocious. We all know that. But it's not always just the teacher's fault. Sometimes it's at least partly the fault of the readers expecting everything to be made simple and immediately accessible with neither work nor effort.

Re:How to Read Mathematics by kenjackson on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @04:05PM (#2707049)
So now, how many ways can this be done? No, it's not five. And no, it's not six either.

An infinite number of ways this can be done.

Re:How to Read Mathematics by ColinWright on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @04:11PM (#2707076)
Yes, but there's more that you can say. In particular, there is more than one infinite family. How many are there? And do all solutions belong to an infinite family? Or are there isolates/sporadics?

Can you characterise the solutions? How many pieces do they contain? Some solutions have two pieces. Some have four. Are there other possibilities?

Re:How to Read Mathematics by kenjackson on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @04:30PM (#2707168)
I don't know what an infinite family, isolate, or sporadic is. A quick Google search didn't make it obvious.

I think 8 pieces also works, but I think that may be it.

Re:How to Read Mathematics by nocipher on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @10:23PM (#2708168)
An infinite family seems to refer to an infinite collection of solutions that are all related in some sense. An isolate or sporadic solution is a solution that is unique and unrelated to other solutions. They are both terms used to categorize solutions.
Re:How to Read Mathematics by kenjackson on Tuesday June 28, 2011 @11:28PM (#2708305)
Thanks nocipher for the definitions. From this I see no sporadics. And two infinite families, at least how I'd classify a family.
Re:How to Read Mathematics by ColinWright on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @03:15AM (#2708683)
nocipher's definition are correct.

And I have, so far, 5 infinite families with, respectively, 2, 4, 8, 16 and 32 pieces.

But details matter, and you might start to question what it really means when I say "piece." Does the definition I've given really capture your intuition?

But I need to go back to writing the article.