News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starting a crypto project by onebot on Thursday May 06, 2021 @11:50AM (#27065095)
Having been part of launching Helium HNT token (which is honestly a real-world utility use case), here is my personal experience related to his points...

Helium started as a traditional centralized IoT project, realized that centralization was a limiting factor, then joked about turning it into a blockchain application. Now it is over $1.5bn market cap and provides a real-world utility.

Exchanges are pay-to-play. It feels bad to interact with them to get listed.

Lots and lots of scammers.

There is still so much untapped value in some possible use-cases, but honestly too many get-rich schemes.

Launching a new layer 1 protocol is a tremendous amount of development effort and I think underestimated by most.

Security is hard.

Scammers/hackers go after all project members personally. You probably aren't prepared for any kind of success.

5 years ago crypto wasn't mainstream. Fast forward to today, and when you say you're in crypto, everyone thinks you're a billionaire.

1.) Decentralization will come for sure (DAO LLC), but no matter what, there is still a Foundation of some kind.

2.) Community depends on utility. There are some amazing strong communities, but is in direct proportoin to the utility the token really brings. Otherwise, just pump and dumpers.

3.) I don't think it is 100% possible to truly decentralize governance. But people are trying.

4.) I don't believe this is true for everything. There are pump and dumpers, but many of the decent tokens today need to focus on utility, the tokens for speculation only will always be manipulated.

5.) I think the VC landscape has changed and maybe a more piling on, but couple of years ago, VCs wouldn't touch crypto and the VCs focusing on crypto (Multicoin, Polychain, etc) are very good and extremely smart.

6.) Time makes no difference. Since it is decentralized it isn't like you have a support team fielding issues. You can't fix anything in a moment's notice. Releases take careful planning and careful testing.

7.) Again this assumes there is no utility in the token. But he is right you can't talk about token price or speculation. But underneath it all you hope the token price goes up.

8.) 100% true. You can't build it and they will just come. It requires real marketing and PR. Most importantly branding. People are looking for value and community around your token. But the early adopters are FOMO speculators.

9.) Yes, legal fees are very high. Could be 7 figures.

10.) Taxes are becoming more clear. Cost basis and capital gains. But a lot depends on how you acquired your token.

11.) Basically, people will constantly claim your are scammers. Literally day and night. And people will spam free bitcoin offers to all your telegram and discord users. Every day and every night.

12.) I think insider trading is unbounded in crypto currency, but that being said a.) its still illegal and not sure founders would be participating in this, b.) its still unclear what really motivates the market. Crypto is heavily retail and the chatter as always be trolls, scammers and naysayers. But also fomo'ers. So hard to say how much insider trading will capitalize on information versus exchanges that can manipulate the volume data. I think whales can manipulate far better than insider trading.

13.) hard to say are we talking a stock market bear market or a crypto bear market?

14.) There are several tokens that have real utility and likely you aren't questioning your lifes' decisions. But lots of sh*tcoin maybe you are. But blockchain (layer 1) developers are still incredibly hard to find--so think they can pick whatever they want to work on.

15.) Again, utility (real use case) or pure speculation play. There are tons of garbage uses of blockchain that are a super poor fit. Hopefully, you don't work for one of those (does supplychain really need to be on a blockchain?)

16.) Unsure if that is true. I think most projects get a halo effect from the success of bitcoin. Most new tokens should be real utility instead of trying to replace bitcoin.

Re:Starting a crypto project by vmception on Thursday May 06, 2021 @04:49PM (#27068878)
I’ve advised many projects, allowing them to inherit my professional network in the crypto space, as well as launched my own tokens.

And the exchanges really are a problem and are still a racket.

It is so great that Uniswap and their style of autonomous liquidity pool creating has taken over, the market was tired of that other bullshit.

Even the most reputable custodial exchanges are a total racket! See Coinbase’s settlement with the CFTC a few weeks back for an example.

The challenges to fixing it are very high, I agree with Gary Gensler’s (SEC chair, former CFTC chair) comments to Congress today about a new regulatory framework for custodial crypto exchanges.

For one: Projects cant talk about exchanges because one part of being considered an unregistered security is by providing an expectation of liquidity!

But communities do have an expectation of liquidity and so does everyone. Otherwise they will attack the founders personally, forever!

The exchanges know this and create extremely toxic relationships, that any complaint from a founder will cause the exchange to completely ruin and slander the project and also delist it, validating any detractors existing beliefs!

Complete racket because the regulators are already taking an adversarial stance and cant even get any insider to talk to them because they’ll go after the insider!

If you arent aware, uniswap (AMMs) and yield fixes this, as communities are providing all of the liquidity and listing of the token for exchange. So honestly the impossible regulatory environment is really being a catalyst for innovation.

Re:Starting a crypto project by swensel on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:16PM (#27071204)
I've used Uniswap and IMO, the UX doesn't compare to the centralized exchanges. I think that will prevent mainstream adoption except for those who are pretty crypto savy. I'm also concerned that decentralized exchanges may have tough regulation applied to them in the future. I'm not sure what that looks like, but it seems like a risk to me. The charges brought against the founder of EtherDelta comes to mind.

That is interesting what you said about the shadiness of centralized exchanges. I wasn't aware of that. Maybe a more clear regulatory framework will help.

However, it seems like whenever more regulation is put upon traditional markets, folks just find a loophole in it and it makes the situation worse for retail investors (best price / HFT comes to mind, but maybe I just took the Flash Boys book too seriously). Anyway, I'm not sure what the answer is there. Curious if you have more thoughts on this.

Re:Starting a crypto project by vmception on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:58PM (#27071572)
Uniswap already has mainstream adoption lol. V2 has had more volume than Coinbase for almost a year and its less than a year old.

People that want alpha learn that interface, the end.

If you want limit orders and big ole' chart taking 3/4ths of the screen so that you can pretend the Bollinger bands are suggesting a breakout, then you have to use third party GUIs, it is all possible and there are plenty of github projects about it. Uniswap V3 makes that even easier.

HFTs already exist here, they provide a service mostly liquidity depth. Crypto exchanges are fairly unique in that they operate many conflicting roles when in other markets they would have fiduciary duties.

Re:Starting a crypto project by swensel on Thursday May 06, 2021 @11:15PM (#27071716)
Thanks! For the adoption, I meant more like new folks to crypto. I think sending someone new to Coinbase is a lot easier than having them set up Metamask, telling them how to get some ETH and sending them to Uniswap (and also having them understand gas fees, etc, otherwise their Uniswap transaction will take hours and maybe be cancelled due to slippage).

Anyway those third party GUIs sound interesting.

I also figured there already was HFTs on crypto, but good to know.

We'll see what happens with potential regulation. I do hope the US understands that not stifling crypto innovation would support them in having companies and leaders in this upcoming field. I do think crypto is in it's early stages at the moment and mainstream adoption to me is having crypto adoption at the level of say the US stock market.

Re:Starting a crypto project by vmception on Friday May 07, 2021 @12:48AM (#27072273)
People can buy eth directly in metamask with dollars

New people to crypto just follow their favorite youtuber

The ux will improve even more over time

The commerce applications on the other side like Uniswap are understood pretty quickly as its just market orders

But there is tons of room for innovation in making it more accessible

When I see the volume, liquidity, value on chain, and all times lows of crypto stored in exchanges, to me that means its easy enough for people to figure it out from their favorite influencer’s bite sized video

Re:Starting a crypto project by PragmaticPulp on Thursday May 06, 2021 @02:36PM (#27067405)
> Helium started as a traditional centralized IoT project, realized that centralization was a limiting factor, then joked about turning it into a blockchain application. Now it is over $1.5bn market cap and provides a real-world utility.

Why did you need to create a new, unique token anyway?

How much of that market cap would you estimate is used for utility versus simply being held for speculation?

Re:Starting a crypto project by onebot on Friday May 07, 2021 @06:14AM (#27074264)
Proof of Coverage was a new model that couldn't be easily done with a layer 2 protocol. I think it could be done now with Solana, but SOL wasn't live when we started.
Re:Starting a crypto project by samsonradu on Thursday May 06, 2021 @04:47PM (#27068860)
> Security is hard.

I'm still wondering how no impactful hacking occured to this day at major exchanges or even the major blockchains. By now it's probably a top-level target worldwide.

Re:Starting a crypto project by swensel on Thursday May 06, 2021 @11:03PM (#27071627)
There have been a few notable hacks to exchanges, Binance, for example [1]. The DAO hack on the Ethereum network, which caused the fork of Ethereum and Ethereum classic, is also notable [2].

I do think the fact that there hasn't been a successful attack on the Bitcoin network is an example of how resilient it is. Safely securing $1 trillion in value on a decentralized network that hasn't been hacked in over a decade of operation, when as you said, it's probably a top-level target, is pretty amazing.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/08/binance-bitcoin-hack-over-40...

[2] https://www.gemini.com/cryptopedia/the-dao-hack-makerdao

Re:Starting a crypto project by garmaine on Friday May 07, 2021 @02:14AM (#27072819)
MtGox? Bitfinex? There has been plenty of hacked tier-1 exchanges.
Re:Starting a crypto project by onebot on Friday May 07, 2021 @06:15AM (#27074275)
Also consider the coins themselves. Hacking (or miscoding) is why there is an Etherium and Etherium classic. They had to hard fork to return funds.