News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by a3n on Thursday May 06, 2021 @03:14AM (#27060069)
> Montana's unemployment rate was 3.8% in March, down from its 11.9% pandemic peak in April 2020, according to data by the Labor Department.

Politicians used to brag about those levels being full employment.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by throwaway_kufu on Thursday May 06, 2021 @03:42AM (#27060225)
> Politicians used to brag about those levels being full employment.

That was before they began openly fudging the numbers. Following 2008 they began removing people from the unemployment numbers once their unemployment benefits expired.

The unemployment rate was never 5% after 2008 and it’s not 3.8% now, millions and millions of people have been written off by politicians using those fake numbers for their reelection campaigns.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by prepend on Thursday May 06, 2021 @07:52AM (#27061853)
> Following 2008 they began removing people from the unemployment numbers once their unemployment benefits expired.

The BLS unemployment rate that’s referenced here is the number of people looking for work who can’t find work [0] so it is meant to measure the percent of the labor force that isn’t working. There are six different rates estimated (U1-U6) and I’m not aware of any that stop counting once unemployment benefits run out. There is a specific stat (U1) to estimate those who have been unemployed for long periods.

[0] https://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm [1] https://courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-economics/chapte...

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by jl2718 on Thursday May 06, 2021 @08:43AM (#27062342)
http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-chart...

What about the 20 million working age on social security? Not counted.

21% of Americans are on means-tested public assistance, which, by definition, requires lack of sustainable employment. Not counted.

A huge number of students can’t find a job. Not counted.

Not that ‘employment’ is a meaningful measure of a society’s desirability.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by prepend on Thursday May 06, 2021 @09:00AM (#27062538)
It depends on what I’m trying to count. If someone is working age and on SSI, then they aren’t capable of working.

The U3 number is trying to measure how much of the total workforce is able to find work. If I can’t or don’t want to work, I’m not part of the workforce.

It’s not that unemployment rate is a measure of “desire ability” (whatever that means) but as a measure of how much labor is available and can work. It’s a useful economic measure, but not an absolute one.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by throwaway_kufu on Thursday May 06, 2021 @08:36AM (#27062264)
See the last section of your link:

> Unemployment insurance (UI) programs are administered at the state level and provide assistance to jobless people who are looking for work.

By definition those receiving unemployment are looking for work. Once you come off unemployment, you are not automatically considered unemployed and seeking work, instead the burden is on you to prove to the BLS you are actively looking for work, this is called marginally attached to the labor force but the catch all is discouraged workers a subset and nearly anyone unemployed that has run through their benefits and still not employed is nearly always going met this definition and they are not considered part of the labor force. (See your link - Who is not in the labor force? )

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by prepend on Thursday May 06, 2021 @09:04AM (#27062585)
This is normally true, but the condition of looking for work was removed with the pandemic unemployment programs, I think because it wasn’t possible to look for work and people needed help.

“Proving” to BLS just means answering a question on a survey, so it’s not burdensome compared to what is required to do continue unemployment insurance. So workers who run out of benefit and answer something like “yes, I’d like to work, am looking, and can’t find” will be included in U3.

There are other measures for underemployed, or people who gave up working, etc. I think those are U4-U6, described in the second link I posted.

I find lots of these arguments are people not understanding the unemployment measures or people arguing with different versions.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by throwaway_kufu on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:06AM (#27063388)
I don’t disagree it amounts to answering a question, and it’s easy to say it’s not a burden.

But on the ground it can be a tremendous burden, we are talking about people who may be avoiding calls because it’s creditors, we are talking about people who don’t have a phone (it’s impossible for most in power to even acknowledge there are people without a phone or even the continuity of continuous phone service - they point to a FCC pledge carriers signed not to do that, but the carriers have do it anyway).

There are many reasons this larger demographic of hidden workforce is not included in the BLS surveys to any meaningful degree, certainly the homeless are not, which I don’t believe in the homeless numbers either, or maybe more diplomatically I should say I believe they are political numbers.

Just as a example, early on we heard politicians discussing mortgages and rent, evictions protections, but once the lawmakers passed the stimulus have you heard any meaningful discussion about any of that? Pre pandemic there were 1M student loans defaulted per year, a long standing trend of adults living at home with parents in record numbers.

Before any of it can be addressed it needs to be acknowledged, it doesn’t help when both sides of the two party political system have consistently taken credit for record unemployment and record stock markets, or eviction protections or FCC pledges to waive late fees and not cut of service, it’s not all fake but it is fake to a meaningful degree. Again we saw something similar with the 2008 bank bailouts and the HAMP and HARP programs, I worked for a law firm briefly that tried to help people and we did to an extent, but for the most part maybe 80% it was banks saying you didn’t submit the paper work, we don’t have it, for months while simultaneously forging ahead in foreclosure cases often with fraudulent documents. To this day politicians champion those programs pointing to a return of the loans with interest, not once addressing the very real systemic problems, fraud and human costs.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by prepend on Thursday May 06, 2021 @06:51PM (#27069891)
You’re providing very basic critiques of all surveys, not just this. Feel free to critique the methods that BLS (and many other big surveys) and you may be able to improve them.

I think they certainly aren’t perfect and this isn’t meant as an absolute measure, but an estimate. So it’s the best measure we have compared to everything else.

Perhaps we should ignore it because it is worse than nothing. But if you read through the methods you’ll see that they plan for the issues you bring up as they are typical for phone surveys.

Also, if we’re just pitching narrative, I expect job seekers to be more likely to be responding to phone and email since they are waiting on interviews to contact them back.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by snarf21 on Thursday May 06, 2021 @09:46AM (#27063109)
Right, it doesn't count non-employment. Politicians got smart, it only matters what the numbers claim to be true. Inflation is calculated differently than it was 30 years ago. It feels to me like healthcare, education, housing, food, etc. are going up year over year.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by LorenPechtel on Thursday May 06, 2021 @01:29PM (#27066518)
I also think the gig economy is messing with the numbers. You have a bit of income from some gig job, you're not unemployed.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by jabroni_salad on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:08AM (#27063425)
I live in Iowa and our unemployment rate pre-pandemic was only 0.3%. There were no special generally available assistance programs available, so I do not think COVID Relief is the cause for the present situation, it's just what returning to normal was always going to look like. There is more demand for labor than there are laborers.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by creshal on Thursday May 06, 2021 @03:20AM (#27060094)
OECD defines a "healthy full employment" rate to be 4-6% unemployment, so the labour pool is unhealthily low already.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by c2h5oh on Thursday May 06, 2021 @03:31AM (#27060163)
Unemployed are defined as "[..] people of working age who are without work, are available for work, and have taken specific steps to find work."

The question is how many people exited the workforce, because both unemployment benefits and minimum wage offer payments that just barely allow them not to starve to death.

Normally people would be incentivized to find work, because even minimum wage would offer a significant upgrade over unemployment benefits, but since minimum wage is so abysmally low they couldn't have set unemployment benefits much lower or people would have literally starved.

The sane solution of increasing minimum wage to incentivize people to find jobs while obvious is not very popular with wealthy political donors.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by jollybean on Thursday May 06, 2021 @07:47AM (#27061814)
That 4-6% is 'healthy' definitely does not mean that lower rates are 'unhealthy'.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by creshal on Thursday May 06, 2021 @08:40AM (#27062316)
But it does. You'll never be able to find jobs for literally everyone (mental illnesses, etc.) and want some slack in the labour pool to handle seasonal fluctuations etc.

If you're literally scraping the barrel, you need to import more workers, or move jobs out of state, or automate some away etc.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by jollybean on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:15AM (#27063536)
That's not unhealthy, it's just not as opportunistic as it could be ... and there's a big difference between those things.

The neoliberal view would be 'more immigration because you could expand' ergo 'unhealthy/unoptimized state, increase people to make more GDP'.

But that's only one view.

Given a flat population, it generally actually wouldn't make a whole lot of sense for example to 'let people go' to create more slack for times of economic swings.

Very low unemployment can only be characterized as 'unhealthy' from the view of 'maximizing GDP growth' for the most part.

Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by prepend on Thursday May 06, 2021 @07:53AM (#27061865)
It means they are not healthy, that is different but probably the same intent.
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by s3tz on Thursday May 06, 2021 @03:24AM (#27060116)
Is it measured the same way though?
Re:Montana to cancel unemployment benefits to address severe... by imtringued on Thursday May 06, 2021 @05:20AM (#27060837)
But are they actually full time employees?

If yes, then it truly is brag-worthy.