I do agree however that the idea alone is not going to get you anywhere.
Taken this way, smt88's estimate seems reasonable.
I said that OP does not have a novel business idea for other people's companies that have (collectively) 500,000 people working for them.
It's wrong to say that no one will invent anything again. It's also wrong to say that, without deep/insider knowledge of a company, that you are smarter and more creative than 100% of their employees. It's laughably arrogant and/or naive.
No, it's not.
It's possible to have an idea they didn't have, but not a good one. It's incredibly arrogant to think you, a random person who doesn't work for a company, has a good and novel idea that their 100,000 employees didn't think of.
And what is the value of an idea with no understanding of their internal operations anyway?
> that's a pretty pessimistic take
OP is asking how to accomplish something that is so uncommon, I have never heard of it in 20 years in the software industry. Never. It doesn't even make logical sense for the company in question.
It's not pessimistic to tell them it isn't going to happen. It's just basic reality. Reality is deflating sometimes -- sorry.
> It's even more possible that they quickly entertained the idea but never pursued it, for a myriad of reasons.
Yes, this is absolutely possible. If it's a good idea, it's actually likely.
And that means it's even less likely that OP is going to be the magical key that opens the lock.
No FAA(M)G-size company has ever said, "Well, this is a great idea, but we just don't have the one person we need to pursue it!" They have the people, and if it were a good idea, they'd pursue it.
Now again, I'm not saying the idea of just going to a FAANG and saying "I've got a good idea, hire me and give me resources" is going to work. I agree with you on this, the chance here is 0. I'm just saying that it might be arrogant, it's likely the OP doesn't have such a brilliant idea, but history shows it is possible to have a good novel idea that matters to those companies.
The startup world is mostly a oroving grouns for execution, not ideas. Successful companies are almost never novel. There is usually an earlier competitor that failed.
The acquisitions are usually projects that have been better executed externally, like YouTube and Android.
The path you're describing (have an idea, get hired to build it) doesn't happen at big tech companies or any other companies that I've ever heard of. Having an idea says nothing about your ability to execute (or whether it's even a good idea).
If you want to get hired as a product manager, either build something yourself and get acquired or go the conventional route of working for someone else.