News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by eganist on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:06PM (#27030649)
Considering the high-profile nature of their partnership as it pertains to the Gates Foundation as well as potential down-stream impacts e.g potentially around which projects are picked up by the foundation, strategic philanthropic decisions, etc., this post would seem to be pretty relevant to the HN community.

Please stop flagging it.

Feel free to downvote me for complaining about the flags, but don't flag the post. No, I'm not OP.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by krapp on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:09PM (#27030682)
No, it isn't. It literally is just mainstream news and celebrity gossip, with nothing to stimulate intellectual curiosity, nothing related to technology, and no new or interesting phenomenon worth discussing. It's bad enough we have to entertain obituary threads but this is a bridge too far.

Two rich people got divorced. Who cares? Flag it into the ground.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by eganist on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:11PM (#27030701)
> No, it isn't. It literally is just celebrity gossip, with nothing to stimulate intellectual curiosity, nothing related to technology, and no new or interesting phenomenon to discuss. It's bad enough we have to entertain obituary threads but this is a bridge too far.

No...... It's literally a tweet from their verified account. It's literally the exact opposite of gossip; it's their official announcement, and this thread provides room for readers here to analyze the effects of the split in our technical, entrepreneurial, and philanthropic context

You know what's gossip? r/relationship_advice, which this isn't. (discl: I run the subreddit)

Please contribute positively.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by DyslexicAtheist on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:24PM (#27030865)
it's also a textbook example of how to announce such news in a positive way (together and without dragging each other to hell).
Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by krapp on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:14PM (#27030732)
I contributed my flag and downvotes.

And fair enough, it's not gossip. Celebrity news still doesn't belong here.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by heartbreak on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:18PM (#27030799)
> It's bad enough we have to entertain obituary threads

It seems your personal relevancy radar is out of sync with the larger HN community. Not a problem in itself, but probably not something you should get up in arms about.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by quenix on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:12PM (#27030709)
This is not gossip. It's about as official as you can get.
Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by detaro on Monday May 03, 2021 @06:43PM (#27031825)
Plenty people saying it shouldn't be flagged, but then not actually commenting on the substance? Why not, if it is relevant?
Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by eganist on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:45PM (#27032357)
Largely because the flagging consumed the oxygen in the room. But there are still comments talking about potential outcomes.

My main concern is around whether the foundation ends up splitting from its current areas of focus (climate change and disease research). There's been a wealth of innovation around both as a consequence of GF's investment and I worry that less focus might mean less funding at a critical time for both.

[dead]
Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by eganist on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @02:27AM (#27034607)
> I am not okay with [...] the whole social distancing narrative

Yikes. That's a flag. At least one reputable study: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/09/200910110824.h...

> free circumcisions to African boys based off of pseudoscientific and absurd research.

On the compound impact of a 1% difference: https://www.politifact.com/article/2016/apr/18/hiv-africa-6-...

The WHO analysis, for independent reading: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/43751/97892...

> even if true it’s still multiple orders of magnitude less cost effective than offering and teaching condom usage.

Announcement of condom innovation funding: https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/bill-gates-condom-campaign...

Progress check: https://www.mic.com/articles/128850/bill-and-melinda-gates-f...

One potential MVP five years after the initial grant round: https://www.businessinsider.com/scientists-invent-self-lubri...

Seems like a multi-layered approach: tackle risk from one side through improved rubbers and further reduce risk on the flip side through medical procedures given the sustained aversion to traditional condoms.

---

It's not really healthy to harbor this amount of unfounded hatred for someone you've (presumably) never met, and I'd advise bringing fact-checked sources next time.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by __blockcipher__ on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:13PM (#27044938)
> Yikes. That's a flag.

You flagged my comment because I expressed an opinion that you disagree with about social distancing? I didn't say it doesn't work to reduce infection (although I absolutely put no stock in associative studies), I said it was a bad thing. I don't believe in constraining human relationships via coercion in order to prevent the spread of a highly infectious respiratory virus that is and was always going to be endemic. What an evil thing to do to use the flag button like that.

Doubly ironic because you linked to an article about a study rather than the actual study, and the study itself is incredibly weak because it's a crappy associative study, which is the only type of study you can really perform for social distancing (which is why it will always be a largely unfalsifiable intervention but I digress)

> Announcement of condom innovation funding: https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/bill-gates-condom-campaign...

That doesn't change the fact that they're spending money on this intervention. Moreover there are obvious ethical concerns with billing genital modification as a medical intervention. We don't take that ethical stance towards FGM, which we rightly decry here in the West as evil. (And before you say that FGM is totally different from male circumcision, you should read up in detail about both, including the multiple different forms of FGM, many of which are analogous to male circumcision; the correct answer is both types of genital mutilation are evil, not just the one we do to girls).

> It's not really healthy to harbor this amount of unfounded hatred for someone you've (presumably) never met, and I'd advise bringing fact-checked sources next time.

You clearly aren't familiar with fact checkers and how they work otherwise you wouldn't use that phrase with a straight face.

And sorry, it is absolutely healthy to harbor a strong distaste for someone that does things you think are evil. I've never met Xi Jinping but I don't like him either.

> On the compound impact of a 1% difference: https://www.politifact.com/article/2016/apr/18/hiv-africa-6-...

First of all politifact is not a neutral source, can we stop collectively pretending that these fact-checker types have any credibility?

Anyway I don't want to get into the whole AIDS-in-Africa debate but maybe you should read up on the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangui_definition and the fact that we regularly diagnose AIDS for things that could very plausibly not be AIDS.

---

I avoided giving sources because I don't want to have to argue the age-old "is it okay to perform a medicalized pseudo-surgery that started out intentionally with the intention of curtailing pleasure and the function of the male sexual organ" debate. But you might be interested in https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1016/S0968-8080%2807... that goes into some interesting history.

On the WHO-Bill-Gates-circumcision-for-HIV thing specifically, there's a great response letter to the original study that points out the glaring flaws (the most shocking that they halted the study halfway through because the results were supposedly so good it was unethical not to circumcise everyone right away...which poor data analysis aside has the obvious confound that you can't have sex for weeks after getting circumcised thus you need a long study period). However I'm having trouble finding it.

Tangentially, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/africans-speak-out-... makes some good points though. Yes it's not a research paper, I'm not trying to say it is.

Re:Bill and Melinda Gates Separated by great_reversal on Monday May 03, 2021 @06:28PM (#27031656)
I agree that the post isn't flag-worthy, but I don't think the content is very relevant to the community either. Although the Gates Foundation and Microsoft share the same founder, the former is nothing like the latter.