https://www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-coronavirus-borders_n_5...
> Trump Appears More Concerned With Closing Borders Than Testing For Coronavirus
> The president has characterized the pandemic as a “foreign virus” and suggested that banning people from other countries is key to fixing the outbreak at home.
NZ had the obvious benefit of being an island with a low population that was able to easily lock their borders down and keep people socially distanced. They didn't pull off some miracle that no one else can figure out.
This point doesn't follow from the article you linked. The HuffPo article has two major complaints:
1) Trump's major focus on dealing with covid at the moment was the existing travel restrictions for China and the new restrictions for Europe. He should have pivoted to addressing the internal spread within the US.
2) Trump was trying to direct blame to specific nationalities/ethnic groups instead of saying that anyone and any travel could be spreading the virus. They were deflect blame by calling it the "Wuhan virus" and "China coronavirus".
I guess the point I'm trying to make is that the manner he closed the borders was xenophobic. Furthermore, he wasn't doing the things necessary to stop the internal spread, and those were more important once the virus arrived. NZ's new cases only started falling in mid-April, a month after Trump's expanded travel restrictions. Additional travel restrictions were necessary, but not sufficient to reduce covid's impact.
http://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/?chart=countri...
* The closure (at least with respect to Europe) occurred by which time it was widely known that the US had uncontrolled community spread.
* The closure applied only to non-Americans, which made it a really, really porous closure. New Zealand's closure applied both to Kiwis and non-Kiwis.
* The administration of the closure was also chaotic and inept. There was no real effort to screen for COVID-19 among the many people who were let in during the closure, and the fact that the arrival halls were jam-packed with people only exacerbated any potential spread that might have happened.
* Similarly, there was no real effort to use the time afforded by the closure (even had it been more effective) to improve testing and tracing infrastructure.
* The actual announcement of the rollout was extremely botched--the White House had to issue three separate statements afterwards correcting Trump's announcement.
* Finally, it's been pretty clear in the months since then that Trump believes that being proactive in the (ineffective) closure efforts is all that he should have done in response to the coronavirus, especially given his pretty active resistance to any further measures.
Conversely, places like Sweden didn't require significant legal restrictions because they have a sense of societal responsibility. When leaders told them to restrict their movement, they listened. They didn't do it as perfectly as if it were enforced or ordered, but they listened (and probably better than Americans listened).
This is the whole problem with the pro-lockdown position. It's turned into an exercise in cherry picking. We don't need to do this, we have global datasets and those can be analysed to try and detect correlations between policies and outcomes. When this analysis has been done, there are no correlations.
Here's a summary of an unusually thorough analysis of global geography vs excess mortality:
https://lockdownsceptics.org/2021/05/03/geography-not-lockdo...
Here's an analysis of mortality vs control stringency across all US states:
https://lockdownsceptics.org/2021/04/24/more-people-died-in-...
Here's a published, peer reviewed paper which says the same thing:
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5...
The thing is, it’s something you have to commit to. You can’t just half ass it.
Some countries have now accrued more public debt than after World War 2. At some point, even the most ardent true believers in this policy have to accept that if entire continents can take measures as extreme as they have done and get no results whatsoever then it is a failed policy.
Wow! This is the best takeaway of this discussion and possibly one of the most quotable statements (and posts) ever made concerning the Covid-19 lockdowns. My hat is off to you, sir.