> It wasn't clear why Yahoo couldn't close on the #1 spot. It had the clear #1 search engine spot in Japan already.
Yahoo is still huge in Japan. According to the statistics I found, Google is #1 with 75% market share and Yahoo is #2 with 19%, but everybody I know around me uses Yahoo.
Also remember at that time that Google, MSN, and Yahoo were the three major search engines at that time. It wasn't clear why Yahoo couldn't close on the #1 spot. It had the clear #1 search engine spot in Japan already. The Yahoo properties (combination of all their websites) was the most popular websites on the internet. They had a much stronger machine learning and data mining research lab, one year bragging that they swept all the best paper awards at the ML/DM computer science conferences.