For comparison, if I made a website for picking a hotel and it showed the price, square footage, sheet thread count and number of TV channels, would I be able to take traffic away from TripAdvisor? Of course not. A hotel could offer a 1000 sq ft room with 1200 thread count sheets and 500 channels for $5 and it could still be the worst hotel on Earth.
Webeiu supports reviews, but it's difficult to have a lot of reviews when starting out. If there was a reliable website with reviews (like Yelp for restaurants), I would show the ratings from that website. Most of the review information about hosts seems to be scattered around in forums, comments, blogs, etc. I have added Alexa and Google ratings to the website pages. These don't mean much for hosting providers, but if people are talking about them, then they will probably have better ranking.
I would definitely welcome any suggestions about a good source of reviews and ratings.
Reliability data of hosting providers is something I definitely want to add. I agree that saving a few dollars should not be the priority, but the search at least narrows down the choices from thousands of plans to a select few.