Re:Dear Google: Do no evil, or comply with the Patriot Act?
by Shenglong on Monday June 27, 2011 @12:24PM
(#2701866)
That's a moral-judgment argument that's landing on the side of a slippery slope. I suppose, the best way to think about this is to address it by adding to it: If the market only has room for one contract killer, and you decide to only take on 75% of the clients who come to you, would it be better for you to stay in the business or let someone else take your place?
Obviously, you face a moral dilemma either way. You don't want to kill, but you can stop 25% of the people from dying, by continuing to kill. I see this as more the situation that Google was in, rather than a flat out replacement logic. Ultimately, I think which way we answer depends on how we see the world, and what moral principles we use to govern our own lives; I doubt everyone will agree on this.
Re:Dear Google: Do no evil, or comply with the Patriot Act?
by corin_ on Monday June 27, 2011 @12:27PM
(#2701879)
True. Also worth remembering, however, is that you can't definitively say that their replacement is doing more/worse than Google would have done - after all, if Google weren't willing to walk away, that could ultimately mean complying with the Chinese government just as much as any other company - we just didn't see it get that bad because they did pull out before then.
And, obviously, don't think I'm comparing web censorship with murder on the moral scale, just comparing the justification for being a part of something you disagree with.