For example, every day I'm dealing with someone who is convinced that the login system is broken. It's always user error, but it requires input from me pretty much every time, to the point of "here is a new temporary password. i've tested it and it works. please copy and paste it in"
Yes, we have an automated "forgot password" feature, but no matter how much automation you add there will always be people who avoid all that and demand personal attention.
Beyond that, I think I'd start "firing" customers who are a huge support drain like that, especially those who are non-paying customers. Unless your site depends heavily on network effects, and a large percentage of visitors have password issues, it sounds like your time could be much better spent elsewhere.
Maybe it helps if you ask some people to perform a specific task while you're watching them (for example your friends). You can learn a lot from that about your design.
That said, you can't please everyone... if you're the one left serving the lowest-IQ users with the lowest-or-no-budget, you just give others an easier time making good money off more savvy software users. Before you know it, you have to close down shop for good...
"Do any of these articles answer your question? If not, click the 'Submit my ticket' button below." One of the articles is titled "Can't log in? Try these steps..."
I assume that's catching some of them, but plenty still click the submit button. You will always have some people who navigate through every automated trap you set up. You can choose to ignore if you want, but your customer service reputation will suffer.
It depends on the target audience. If it consists of geeks/people familiar with computers from an early age, then, yes, they might read that, otherwise you're going to do what MicahWedemeyer does (and what myself I'm doing, for a Groupon-clone website targeted to women): emailing your users predefined passwords, hoping they'll actually change them after the first time they use them.
You shouldn't be "hoping" anything.
> you should immediately route them into a password-change workflow on login
We already have that by default (we're using Drupal), but, as I said, most of our target audience finds it too complicated.
The other option is wire transfer (which is very common in many European countries unlike in the US). The advantage here is that nobody needs to share any personal information. I just receive the money on a bank account. So far, there was no need to process that money automatically. I just wrote a little script, which greps for the transaction ID and the amount of money and prolongs an account accordingly.
I do not have an automated recurring payment system. All payments are "one shot", like a prepaid service. I can imagine that this is something people really appreciate. They feel more in control of their money and manually entering the payment information once every 6 or 12 months isn't too much of a hazzle.
Furthermore, I ask for as few personal information as possible. I don't store credit card information on my site. Heck, I don't even store real names in my database (but they are shown in PayPal).
YMMV.
Now, it's time to consider the extremely likely possibiliy that you could charge 5x the amount and without decreasing conversion by 5x. Which means you could probably be earning 5x than you are now (or more) without any extra work.
I ran a website for a couple of years without thinking about turning it into a business. Finally, shortly before I graduated, I decided that I need to make money from it, otherwise I can't sustain it any more. Over the years, 30,000 people used my "startup" and in the end, I had a round 5,500 active users.
I thought a lot about the pricing model, but turning a free service into a paid one, is not easy and truth is, I'll never find out how it would perform with a different pricing model. So I just made a decision and tried it. I decided against freemium and started charging 1€ at the beginning of this year. The intention was to make it a no-brainer and convert as many users as possible. I converted about 50% of them. People pay either 6 or 12 months in advance (to lower the transaction costs).
My greatest fear was that there would be a lot of people who are not satisfied and want their money back or that I'll end up spending a lot of time on support emails.
Thruth is, from now 4,000 paying customers. I had exactly 1 person who wanted his money back. I receive about 2-5 emails per day, mostly telling me how great the service is and what kind of features they would like to see.
I literally spend 10 minutes per day on customer support.
Fact is, it depends on your business and something that doesn't get mentioned in the blog is that people don't care too much about a lousy dollar or euro per month to complain about something (some do, however, but rarely).