News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by jeffbee on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:59AM (#27015352)
Google announced they had 35 million commits to their monorepo, five years ago.
Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by WanderPanda on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:03AM (#27015388)
Do they have a quick response team to incarcerate newbies who commit binaries to their giant monster?
Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by jeffbee on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:13AM (#27015486)
No, because piper doesn’t care how big your files are, and devs don’t ever need to pull or clone the repo locally.

When they were still using actual Perforce there was a team who would browbeat people who had more than a hundred clients. That is they only time I can remember running up against a limit of the SCM.

Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by quantumofalpha on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:08PM (#27016378)
That's a non-issue for scalable version control systems they use - perforce and now its in-house replacement (piper).

Gamedev companies LOVE perforce because it scales, they keep game assets in it and those can be huge.

Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by CivBase on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:21PM (#27016465)
By "scalable" I assume you mean "centralized". As in the repository is hosted on a single machine, so you only have to worry about one machine meeting the hardware requirements for storing all that data. That scales better with repo size, but it scales worse with the size of your development team. I'm sure the Linux kernel has orders of magnitude more developers than a typical video game or engine.
Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by quantumofalpha on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:42PM (#27016620)
> By "scalable" I assume you mean "centralized".

Yes, at scale it has to be. Google has hundreds of terabytes of data in their monorepo, you can't check out it all! Historically centralized used to be the norm - previous popular VCS generations (CVS, subversion) are all like that. DVCS (git & co) came into dominance only in the last decade or so.

> That scales better with repo size, but it scales worse with the size of your development team.

Google switched to piper around 2014 when they had ~50k employees. Perforce monorepo worked pretty well for them until then. It has certain costs to scale a monorepo that far - lots of investment into tooling to make it all work, needs dedicated teams. But it can be scaled. And it offers certain benefits that are very difficult to harness in multi-repo setups - ability to reason about and refactor code across entire repo is the biggest one.

> I'm sure the Linux kernel has orders of magnitude more developers than a typical video game or engine

Linux kernel development is very different, decentralized across many different companies and ICs, hence the need for DVCS systems like git. In a corporate environment like google or gamedev, it is much easier to keep version control centralized and dedicate a team to maintaining it.

Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by CivBase on Sunday May 02, 2021 @02:30PM (#27017594)
Right. I just wanted to point out that centralized and distributed version control are both designed to scale, just in different ways.
Re:The Linux kernel has surpassed one million git commits by eru on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:14AM (#27015494)
They have extensive code review.