News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on We are desensitized to Christianity’s influence on Western thought. Parent comment

Re:We are desensitized to Christianity’s influence on Wester... by nobodyCloak on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:06PM (#27011448)
At least in the context of this essay this point seems moot to me. Whether the author argues that only Christianity provided such theories or not, the vast majority of the US founders cite the Christian God as the source of a lot of things, human rights among them. They don’t cite some Greek philosopher because that’s not what they pulled that aspect of their argument from.

Maybe this is just more cut snd dry for me because I’ve studied US history for years and I’m imposing a lot of that into the essay, but I don’t think the author is being disingenuous at all for rightly pointing out the reaching effect of Christianity on our modern understanding of human rights (see Locke’s “Reasonableness of Christianity” for some fun reading).

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:We are desensitized to Christianity’s influence on Wester... by jwhitlark on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:32PM (#27011885)
Many writings of the founders were absolutely rife with references to antiquity and classical authors, it was a common practice of the time to write under a Roman republic era pseudonym, and off the top of my head, Jefferson and Adams knew Latin, Madison knew Greek and Latin, and they all were definitely well versed in the classics.

Maybe we're talking past each other, but the essay seemed to be arguing that Christianity was both the source and only legitimate basis for modern human rights, and I don't think the historical record supports that argument at all.

[ Parent | on HN ]