News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Saturday May 01, 2021 @07:59PM (#27011092)
Equally, a built-in, one-tap-to-install app store with frictionless payment led to an explosion of software creation and developer revenue. Trust was a huge problem, distribution was a huge problem, and Apple solved both.

It's important to keep in mind that this "explosion" of developer revenue is mostly in scammy pay to play games. Apple's app store rules have made it very difficult to build the kind of software business that flourished in the older model where users paid for significant feature upgrades. Apple's answer to this is pushing everything into a subscription model or awkward bundles of in-app purchases which I argue has not been to the benefit of users or most developers.

Re:Resetting the App Store by pedalpete on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:08PM (#27011462)
I don't believe the subscription model was "Apple's answer", it was probably coming along anyway. It made it somewhat easier with th app store, and perhaps gave it a push, but running a business with a subscription model, particularly in consumer software, has huge benefits to the business.

It lets you charge a smaller amount up front, to get more people trying, and paying for your software, but keeps an ongoing revenue stream to keep the business going as well.

Re:Resetting the App Store by kalleboo on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:10PM (#27011793)
As an iOS developer, Apple developer relations has been HEAVILY courting us to adopt subscriptions for our app. With long Keynote presentations extolling all the virtues and showing sample case studies and everything.

We would prefer the traditional model of "pay for major feature updates every years" but the app store does not support that.

Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:20PM (#27011516)
Subscriptions are great if you can get your users to sign up for one. But most people are very reluctant to add another subscription to the list of monthly bills they have to pay. For example I might pay $10 every year or two to upgrade a nice photo editing app on my phone and I might even buy several of these but I'm extremely reluctant to sign up for a monthly charge for an app like this and if I do it will only be one.
Re:Resetting the App Store by iscrewyou on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:43PM (#27011943)
I’ve abandoned many apps because of subscription push. Subscriptions are somewhat like credit cards. I wonder if people realize the monthly increase in prices to their bills is like signing up for cable back in the day.

Sometimes the simplest app having a subscription seems like pure greed from the developer. The excuses are generally that of increase in development costs. But maybe that is equivalent to increasing the cost of development like increasing the cost of living when there is extra money coming in.

Re:Resetting the App Store by jolux on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:35AM (#27013080)
Why do people always call this greed? Folks need to eat, and I don’t think it’s wrong to want to be able to support a living writing software. Developers should price their software as they see fit, it’s a reflection of their business decisions, not their personal vices. You don’t have to pay them for it if you don’t want to. That’s the way capitalism has always worked, people are looking out for their rational self-interest.
Re:Resetting the App Store by LocalH on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:40AM (#27015195)
I don't think that taking something that was once "pay once and get a perpetual license to that specific version" and turning it into "pay $X per month or lose access to the software" is a good thing when it becomes the dominant form of software access. It's fine for that to be an option, but not as the only way.
Re:Resetting the App Store by jolux on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:42AM (#27016192)
I mostly agree, I think the JetBrains model where your subscription also buys a perpetual license to the last year you paid for is the best (I’m a happy customer of their all products subscription). But Apple hasn’t made that model easy in the App Store.
Re:Resetting the App Store by chihuahua on Saturday May 01, 2021 @11:06PM (#27012032)
Yeah I decided a long time ago that I'm not playing that game, adding subscriptions for all kinds of things.

The only recurring charge I pay for is Amazon Prime, because I don't want to think about shipping costs and I like Prime Video (replaces Netflix) and Fresh (free grocery delivery, no need for Instacart)

Other than that, anything that requires a subscription, I can do without.

I've bought one mobile app in my life: Backcountry Navigator. It lets me download detailed maps for hiking and then use them where there's no cellphone towers. The free version was good enough, but it was so useful that it felt better to pay the developer his $7 for lifetime usage (no recurring charge)

Re:Resetting the App Store by pedalpete on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:55AM (#27012472)
I hadn't heard of Backcountry Navigator before. Just looked at their website which states "some maps require an additional subscription." you maybe you got in on the app before they moved to subscription?
Re:Resetting the App Store by chihuahua on Sunday May 02, 2021 @02:29AM (#27012797)
It's true that I bought it about 5 years ago and things may have changed since then.

But I think the sentence you're quoting is referring to the following: BC Navigator allows you to download maps for offline use from a variety of sources. Most of these sources are free (e.g. Open Cycle Map [related to OpenStreetMap], US Forest Service, etc) and some require a paid account with the map provider (e.g. CalTopo). So if you want to use the CalTopo maps, you need to pay CalTopo. But it's perfectly fine with the free maps.

The UI used to be pretty difficult to figure out. After a year I got used to it and it's fine. But they released a new version for iPhone which is supposedly quite different from the early Android version, and they claim they put more effort into making it easier to use.

Another thing that's very useful about BC Navigator is that you can easily import GPX tracks (e.g. planned routes) and overlay them on the map in different colors. So you can have your main route for the day, and maybe some alternate routes for a section where you're not sure if the original route is going to work out. You can keep an entire library of routes in the app, and select which ones you want to show that day.

It's just a perfect app for what I love to do - mountain biking in places where few people go.

Re:Resetting the App Store by matkoniecz on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:12AM (#27012996)
> Open Cycle Map [related to OpenStreetMap]

To be more specific https://www.opencyclemap.org/ is generated from OpenStreetMap data and some terrain data, likely SRTM.

Re:Resetting the App Store by cudgy on Sunday May 02, 2021 @04:37AM (#27013406)
Why should app developers even care about the opinions of non-paying customers like yourself that never buy apps? It’s obviously not sustainable.
Re:Resetting the App Store by chihuahua on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:27PM (#27021021)
That is correct, they should not care about my opinion on this subject.

I'm happy that I can get by without paying for monthly subscriptions. I am also happy if there are lots of other people who find enough value in these services to make it worth paying for.

Re:Resetting the App Store by fshbbdssbbgdd on Saturday May 01, 2021 @08:57PM (#27011403)
Is it true empirically that independent developer software sales are lower on mobile than desktop? I definitely spend more on mobile apps, and I’m a software engineer who spends a lot of time on desktop. My impression is that the mobile app ecosystem has massively grown the market. Subscriptions are lucrative, so platform support for that only helps developers.
Re:Resetting the App Store by frosted-flakes on Saturday May 01, 2021 @11:22PM (#27012103)
I've spent no more than $50 on mobile software in the last decade, but more than $1000 for desktop software. The difference is that mobile apps are cheap and single-function, but desktop software is feature-rich and expensive. So even if I buy a lot of apps, I still spend more on desktop software. That is an anecdote, but I expect it's broadly true for the wider population.

Even for games, I wouldn't blink at spending $50 on a PC or Nintendo Switch game, but for some reason I would never spend more than $5 for a mobile game.

Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:22PM (#27011529)
> Apple's app store rules have made it very difficult to build the kind of software business that flourished in the older model where users paid for significant feature upgrades.

This era was remembered with fondness, but there were hardly any of these businesses compared to the number of software companies that exist today.

Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:31PM (#27011595)
Software is now deeply integrated into every aspect of our lives. It's expected that there's a lot more of it. What we don't know is how many and what variety of software companies would exist if the app store wasn't so obviously designed to commodify the complement of Apple's iPhone cash cow.
Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:16PM (#27011815)
> wasn't so obviously designed to commodify the complement of Apple's iPhone cash cow

This makes no sense whatsoever. High quality apps are in Apple’s interest because they need to compete against Android and the web.

The reason the app business model is hard, is that there is a lot of money, enormous competition now, and no intellectual property protection. Nothing more. If anything the App Store has slowed the commodification.

Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:29PM (#27011879)
Compare what kinds of music making tools are available inside the app store and outside the app store and you'll see this is completely not the case. There is tremendous competition outside the app store in this market but devs can still charge $200+ for a single very high quality product and make a good living selling paid upgrades. Users will crucify you for trying to charge $200 for anything in the app store. It's digital serfdom for devs.
Re:Resetting the App Store by nl on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:46PM (#27011960)
The fact that price expectations are different for mobile apps and desktop apps doesn't reflect on the appstore model at all.

You can charge hundreds in the MacOS appstore and no one blinks.

People expect mobile apps to cost a few dollars. This might not be fair but isn't really due to the appstore in any way I can see.

Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Saturday May 01, 2021 @11:11PM (#27012059)
Those same devs also do not sell their products in the Mac app store for the same reason. Too many restrictions and prices trending to the bottom.
Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:28AM (#27015108)
Prices are tending towards the bottom because of competition.

I don’t like it but that’s not a result of the App Store model.

It’s a result of the democratization and globalization of software development.

Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:31AM (#27016110)
Logic Pro is in the Mac App Store at $200. It’s very popular.
Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:24PM (#27020696)
Only because Apple can afford to sell it at break even or a loss. All the comparable packages from third parties are at least 3x that price and nobody's getting rich there.
Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:24PM (#27028810)
You are the one who mentioned the $200 price point. Was that not correct?
Re:Resetting the App Store by cageface on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:17PM (#27033382)
$200 is what a single high quality plugin costs. Complete DAW packages with many bundled plugins like Ableton or Cubase are at least 3x that price.
Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:41AM (#27038099)
Ok, but it seems implausible that there would be a significant market for those on the iPhone even if there was no App Store.
Re:Resetting the App Store by lupinglade on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:26PM (#27011568)
Quantity != Quality, though.
Re:Resetting the App Store by zepto on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:13PM (#27011803)
Agreed. But the quantity of good software is higher too.