Re:Google-led paper pushes back against claims of AI ineffic...
by theptip on Friday April 30, 2021 @11:21AM
(#26994590)
Cars are a terrible measuring stick here, the article should know better. A car is for one household, or maybe one person. These models can potentially serve billions of people once trained. You can’t meaningfully evaluate their efficiency without the denominator.
Per capita per year is the right unit to be using here.
Re:Google-led paper pushes back against claims of AI ineffic...
by jhgb on Friday April 30, 2021 @11:43AM
(#26994935)
Right. How much CO2 does it take to train a single human from birth to do something? And, once trained, that human will still be way slower at many tasks than a trained machine.
Re:Google-led paper pushes back against claims of AI ineffic...
by Jabbles on Friday April 30, 2021 @10:22AM
(#26993837)
Indeed - the graphic that compares the CO2e of 1 passenger's portion of a flight instead of the whole flight is particularly bad, given that the model is something that will be used by multiple people:
https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/06/06/239031/training-...
Re:Google-led paper pushes back against claims of AI ineffic...
by goatcode on Friday April 30, 2021 @10:18AM
(#26993788)
"It uses too much electricity" has become the new curmudgeon punt. I've begun ignoring it outright. Thank you for spelling out the bigger picture for those who are pondering the silly abuse of environmental concern signaling bandwagon. Maybe someday we can combat actual threats to our environment, probably using AI.
Re:Google-led paper pushes back against claims of AI ineffic...
by hobs on Friday April 30, 2021 @11:39AM
(#26994866)
If complaining about waste, compare it to what you could achieve with the same resources. Ignoring something outright is not a good approach, you basically have created an opposite tribe with the same illogical basis.
If we can do the same work in 1/10000th the effort, then we should decry the waste.
These news articles are hyperbolic and not addressing the true waste we have in society. Once again I’m not arguing that there isn’t inefficiency and waste, but we’re ignoring the fact that every one of the those Google users (or at least a substantial amount) has a higher carbon footprint in totality that FAR surpasses that of a single model. I do support further research in this area, but we must consider the harm us engineers cause when we write papers that can be manipulated so well by media to create click bait articles that only enable the mindset of “big tech is the actual problem” while individuals shift responsibility of their own carbon emissions onto others.