Re:Flu has disappeared worldwide during the Covid pandemic
by timr on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:34PM
(#26986361)
> we also have evidence in the actual observations of epidemic dynamics. Over the southern hemisphere fall of 2020 (northern hemisphere spring), covid cases increased more rapidly than influenza cases in countries that were entering their flu seasons. That's compelling-to-me evidence that covid in fact has a larger basic reproductive number
Yes, we know that SARS-CoV2 increased, and influenza went away. That's trivially observed. We don't know why flu went away.
To turn that observation around and say "Covid grew faster than flu, and therefore it has a higher R0, and therefore, the flu went away because {insert your favorite NPI} was just good enough to stop it" is begging the question.
It could just as easily be any number of other factors that you're not accounting for. There's also a number of other faulty assumptions inherent in your logic. For starters: there's no particular reason, a priori, that a person couldn't have both flu and SARS-CoV2 in the same year.
Yes, we know that SARS-CoV2 increased, and influenza went away. That's trivially observed. We don't know why flu went away.
To turn that observation around and say "Covid grew faster than flu, and therefore it has a higher R0, and therefore, the flu went away because {insert your favorite NPI} was just good enough to stop it" is begging the question.
It could just as easily be any number of other factors that you're not accounting for. There's also a number of other faulty assumptions inherent in your logic. For starters: there's no particular reason, a priori, that a person couldn't have both flu and SARS-CoV2 in the same year.