Re:Skype’s Worthless Employee Stock Option Plan: Here’s Why ...
by e40 on Sunday June 26, 2011 @02:15PM
(#2698615)
All well and good, if they made this clear to the employees who were fired when they were hired. "Oh, and I'd like to point out that if you're terminated before a liquidity event, we can purchase all your stock back, even the shares you purchased. You know, this isn't a startup. We're in this to flip this sucker over and make a ton. If you're with us at the end, then you'll benefit, otherwise you won't."
Re:Skype’s Worthless Employee Stock Option Plan: Here’s Why ...
by pbreit on Sunday June 26, 2011 @12:54PM
(#2698394)
"a huge amount of employee owned stock in the US is subject to similar provisions"
Are you sure about this? Most folks are saying this is quite rare, startup or large co, public or private. I, myself, have never seen such terms.
Re:Skype’s Worthless Employee Stock Option Plan: Here’s Why ...
by brudgers on Sunday June 26, 2011 @01:11PM
(#2698436)
It's extremely common in small business because they are privately held with no intention of ever going public (and therefore often closely held as well).
Big companies usually are publicly traded and startups are usually structured to allow becoming publicly traded. <IANAL> Therefore such restrictions on common stock are not practical <IANAL>.
Privately held companies don't operate with the same logic as startups or publicly traded corporations, and private equity operates in a way that is even more radically different because they often seek to dismantle a company by selling off its assets often to the point of complete liquidation.
This is irrelevant because Skype is not a startup. It is an established company. In addition it is a private company not a publicly traded one and a company with no intention of becoming a public company (indeed it never was a public company - though it has been part during eBay's ownership).
The techpress keeps spinning this as a story about startups while ignoring the difference between Private Equity firms which invest in mature companies which are distressed and Venture Capital firms which invest in small companies with a high potential for growth.
The techpress would do well to get outside the Silicon Valley echo chamber once in a while.
As is the case with Skype and Silverlake, private equity firms tend to be focused on flipping companies. Like people flipping houses on cable network reality shows, they don't establish the sort of personal attachment which investors in a startup need because at the point private equity becomes involved founders don't have much power and the owners (i.e. shareholders) are looking to liquidate their investment not dilute it on the expectation of future company growth.
In the vast majority of privately held companies, the practical effect of stock ownership is the receipt of dividends because most closely held companies are not focused on growth in the manner that startups are. Buy-sell such as those at Skype are typical - share price escalation is typically undesirable because of potential tax implications and liquidity issues. Therefore, buy-sell agreements usually require selling shares back upon the end of employment. The greater flexibility private companies enjoy when compared to public companies in negotiating the terms of employment often are used to mitigate the effect when employees with large numbers of shares leave. When a low level employee leaves, however, the break is clean and complete in a way which keeps disgruntled ex-employees out of shareholder meetings.
Sure the former shareholders can sue Skype, anyone can sue anyone in the US. But it's hard to see how they will substantial precedent given that a huge amount of employee owned stock in the US is subject to provisions similar to those in the Skype agreement.