News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by 01100011 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:35PM (#26972552)
I think you can make a solid case that, for most people, fructose and therefore sucrose is bad in any significant quantity. Sure, fructose can help replenish liver energy stores if you're an athlete, but most people aren't.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by knuthsat on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:38PM (#26972609)
This is not true. The Robert Lustig scaremongering is a big lie. In his talk he mentions the healthy Japanese but he does not mention that they eat more calories from fructose (in percentage of their consumed calories) than USA citizens yet are healthier.

Similarly how people stand against epidemiology they should stand against demonizing single ingredients.

Apple, by Lustig's opinion, is the worst fruit there is but he will never, in a scientific study, demonstrate the ill-effects of consuming apples, while another group consumes the same equivalent amount of raw fructose extract.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by cycrutchfield on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:46PM (#26972682)
Why are you mischaracterizing Lustig's position?

https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/07/31/making-the-case-fo...

>Another nutrition expert, Dr. Robert Lustig, a professor of pediatrics at the University of California, San Francisco, who has called sugar “toxic” at high doses and fructose the most “actionable” problem in our diet, is still a fan of fruit. “As far as I’m concerned, fiber is the reason to eat fruit,” since it promotes satiety and the slow release of sugar.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by knuthsat on Thursday April 29, 2021 @10:08AM (#26981350)
I'm not. Fruit isn't apple. Apple is fruit with massive amounts of fructose.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:51PM (#26972726)
There are lots of examples that support your argument.

For example, there are hunter-gatherer tribes living today that consume a significant amount of sugar (up to 60% of their calories) and don't have the same problems with obesity, diabetes, etc.

I'm no expert but it seems that the human body doesn't handle bodyfat very well. Perhaps all of this negativity around sugar can be explained by the fact that sugar is calorie-dense and calorie-dense foods tend to make people fat. Especially in the hyper-palatable forms we have in America.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by at-fates-hands on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:23PM (#26973055)
>> there are hunter-gatherer tribes living today that consume a significant amount of sugar (up to 60% of their calories) and don't have the same problems with obesity, diabetes,

The reason they don't have those issues is they are constantly burning calories and in constant motion. H/G is not an easy life and those tribes (both men and women) put in a ton of manual labor. In college I remember one film where a tribe in Papua New Guinea were shown climbing a 15ft tall palm tree. All three males they showed were totally shredded. Six pack, lean upper bodies, biceps and legs were all cut.

I would imagine the sugar gets burned up pretty quickly and it not only a source of calories but a primary source of energy - which is needed for how they live.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:38PM (#26973204)
That supports my claim. If they burn off the calories then they wont get fat and therefore avoid metabolic issues.

My whole point is that the bodyfat is causing the issues. If sugar was the root cause then we should be seeing diabetes, etc. in these hunter-gatherer tribes.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by at-fates-hands on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:56PM (#26973429)
Yeah, I should've been more clear that I was supporting what you were saying and agree with your point.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:52PM (#26974044)
Gotcha. My bad.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by cycrutchfield on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:55PM (#26972786)
Really, hunter-gatherer tribes eat 60% of their calories in refined sugars? Or are you conflating any form of sugar (specifically in fruit) and refined sugars such as in soft drinks?
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:59PM (#26972812)
No I'm talking about honey or plain white sugar depending on the tribe.

I forgot their names but there are 3 main tribes that I remember being studied. Two of them ate significant amounts of honey and a third traded for refined white sugar.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by cycrutchfield on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:08PM (#26972918)
Got it, I think this may be one that you were referring to? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadza_people

>Honey represents a substantial portion of the Hadza diet (~10-20% of calories)

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:28PM (#26973106)
As a followup here's a paper on the various tribes. Sorry I don't have a download link to the full PDF: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24746602/

In that paper they also reference the Mbuti pygmies of the Congo. Specifically: "The Mbuti of the Congo forests eat large amounts of honey. According to Ichikawa (1981), honey is their favorite food. At times, during the rainy season up to 80% of the calories in their diet come from honey."

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by Malician on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:06PM (#26973548)
I wonder, though, what happens if you investigate the important variables - "up to", "during the rainy season," - maybe the human body can tolerate this for short periods of time, but not 24/7; and pygmies makes me think lower growth hormone / IGF-1, so the impact of the sugar may not be near as bad
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:23PM (#26973716)
Other tribes consistently eat as much or more sugar than westerners on average. So I'm not sure if what you're saying can explain the difference.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:12PM (#26972950)
Yep that's one of them. They eat roughly the same amount on average as UK citizens but don't have the metabolic issues.

There is another tribe that will eat up to 60% of their calories from honey depending on the availability of food.

Another tribe trades with first-world countries for white sugar.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:55PM (#26972782)
> Perhaps all of this negativity around sugar can be explained by the fact that sugar is calorie-dense and calorie-dense foods tend to make people fat.

Sugar is less calorie dense than fat, and this kind of naive reductionist CICO thinking would tend to support the war on fat that preceded recognition of the problems associated with sugar.

It’s true that humans are not well adapted to deal with persistent surplus, but sugary persistent surplus seems to be a particular problem.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by serverholic on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @07:20PM (#26975475)
> Sugar is less calorie dense than fat

Yes. I never said that it wasn't.

> naive reductionist CICO thinking

CICO is how the body works. If you absorb more calories than you burn you will gain weight. It also doesn't matter the source of the calories. We have metabolic ward studies that tell us that.

> sugary persistent surplus seems to be a particular problem

I agree. In fact one of the prevailing theories of diabetes is that fat molecules enter the cell and get in the way of insulin absorption. In other words, insulin resistance.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by fiddlerwoaroof on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:57PM (#26972802)
Yeah, this has been my general takeaway: calorie-counting and things like intermittent fasting are much more important than reading ingredient labels (for people who don’t have allergies and diet-related health issues like diabetes).
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by deepnotderp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:48PM (#26972700)
Fruits are metabolized very differently than their extracted sugar content though
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by knuthsat on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:19PM (#26973676)
Exactly, yet all of the studies blaming sugar concentrate on fructose and glucose concentrate studies.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by dataflow on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:56PM (#26972791)
> he will never, in a scientific study, demonstrate the ill-effects of consuming apples, while another group consumes the same equivalent amount of raw fructose extract.

I can imagine lots of reasons for not running this study. Maybe there's no funding or interest in it. Or maybe it falls short of proving what you're hoping it proves. Or maybe he's busy with a dozen other things. I have no idea. It's certainly an effort that needs to be justified. Just saying he isn't doing something isn't particularly enlightening. Much better would be if you could link to some other study on this and show the results didn't match what he claims.

> In his talk he mentions the healthy Japanese but he does not mention that they eat more calories from fructose (in percentage of their consumed calories) than USA citizens yet are healthier.

No comment on Lustig in general, but 3 comments on your criticism:

- He literally says in his talk that the Japanese diet "eliminates fructose". So it's not really that he doesn't mention what you're saying; he actually claims the opposite is true, so he addresses this head-on. Do you have a link or something (for those who don't know) that show's he's wrong about this you could share? You could try to shoot down down his argument if you show he's wrong on that basic fact. Make sure you get the details correct, though, like the time period (in case things have been changing).

- "Healthier" is too vague. They could be doing better on lots of metrics but not the particular one he's talking about, but come out "healthier" overall.

- Similarly, there could be a million and one other things that they do differently from Americans that could make up for whatever damage fructose is alleged to do. Just because the end result is that they're healthier and that they consumer more fructose doesn't mean fructose isn't having a negative effect on them.

You haven't really provided any more support for your argument than he has at all, so it's hard to take your word over his (regardless of whose might be right). If you have something to support your position that would be super helpful.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by fnord77 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:45PM (#26972671)
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by skohan on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:40PM (#26972627)
Yes exactly. Sugar should probably be placed in the same category as alcohol in terms of health consideration. It's fine to enjoy in moderation, but fundamentally toxic. Less acutely toxic than alcohol, but more strongly habit-forming.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by sachdevap on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:05PM (#26972884)
Sugar is not fundamentally toxic. This is a very poor conclusion to draw, and even more so when, as someone else suggested, expanding this to all carbs.

Glucose is used in IV drips, and in emergency conditions, providing someone with glucose and electrolytes can prevent them from passing out.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by cycrutchfield on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:12PM (#26972941)
When people say sugar they are generally referring to sucrose. When they say that sugar is toxic, it's not because it's broken down into glucose, it's because it is also broken down into fructose.

The metabolism of fructose is somewhat analogous to that of ethanol.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3649103/

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by parineum on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:14PM (#26972967)
> The metabolism of fructose is somewhat analogous to that of ethanol.

Does that mean it's toxic?

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by knuthsat on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:21PM (#26973695)
Of course not, because that study analyzes concentrates and not natural source of fructose. Eating the equivalent amount of fructose used in those studies in fruit will never get you similar effects to ethanol. These studies are interesting but vacuous.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:01PM (#26972835)
I would go ahead and throw all carbs in there with the level of inactivity among most of the population.
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by eloff on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:04PM (#26972878)
No, because there are plenty of healthy carbs, especially in moderation.

There is no healthy sugar by comparison.

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by renewiltord on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:38PM (#26972605)
This always confused me. Why does the WHO only have guidelines on "added sugar", why not all sugar?

Based on a naive reading of things, I removed fruit from my diet as well, but that's against WHO guidelines: I used to eat like 3 Fuji/Envy a day (haha).

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by bellyfullofbac on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:49PM (#26972707)
I remember reading a news story that an international organization (in my memory it was the UN) wanted to issue a warning about all sugar, but the US government representatives lobbied hard for the wording to be changed, because of the US food industry.

Sadly I once tried to refind this story by googling but couldn't find it again, so I might as well be screaming, "the second coming is nigh!"

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by renewiltord on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:53PM (#26972757)
It's got to be either this or some sort of absorption mechanism with fiber+fructose, right? I've heard the following few, but I have no evidence:

* The lobbying thing

* That fiber gets you full so you don't eat as much fructose

* That fiber modifies the absorption process

Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by andi999 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:09PM (#26972920)
Then juice, especially orange juice should be as bad as sugar (which I think it is).
Re:Sugar-sweetened beverage intake and serum testosterone le... by nextos on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:27PM (#26973098)
It's really well known that fiber interacts with the gut microbiome and the immune system. There's at least a decade of mainstream publications backing up that fiber helps inducing regulatory T cells. These are needed to avoid inflammation.