News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by ronnier on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:18PM (#26971086)
Comcast makes me sick. I spent months getting off of them and it was worth every bit of it by switching to Ziply fiber in the Seattle area. I went from this to this:

* Comcast 1000/35 Down/up to Ziply 1000/1000 down/up

* Monthly bill cut in half

* Comcast monthly data caps, to no data caps with Ziply

And that's right, Comcast gives 35 Mbps upload, if you are lucky! And data caps.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:51PM (#26971511)
In NYC, I have exactly one broadband provider. Spectrum (formerly Time Warner). Their highest end package is 500 down / 20 up. I can't get FiOS because, even though Verizon contractually agreed to wire all of NYC up for fiber, they lied and didn't. So, my only other option is Verizon DSL with offers 'up to 7Mbps' down.

T-Mobile is rolling out their home 5g internet now. It doesn't support streaming yet, but it hits around 200+ down and 25 up on my phone, so it may get there.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by sinak on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:30PM (#26971940)
If anyone is considering T-Mobile Home 5G Internet, you can dramatically improve your connection speeds by getting the devices to connect on the 5G n41 band, where T-Mobile has much more spectrum. Unfortunately n41 is 2500 MHz, which means it's readily absorbed by building materials. Hooking up external antennas to the hotspot requires a bit of playing with the device [1], but can be a big help.

https://www.waveform.com/a/b/guides/hotspots/t-mobile-5g-gat...

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by ep103 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:09PM (#26971706)
nyc has sued verizon multiple (?) times for failing to roll out fiber into the city and just keeping the money. Each time verizon does some update, or rolls out a little bit more, and the story repeats. Telecom is a utility, end of story.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by toss1 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:19PM (#26972386)
NYC needs to get serious

Tell Verizon and the others that if they fail to fulfill their contract, the will get their license pulled, or, at the very least, they will operate their own local municipal broadband.

Of course the incentives are probably for each individual politician such that with enough graft, campaign donations, etc., that they just stick with the status quo, but I'm not familiar with the local situation.

[edit: typo "fulled" => "pulled"]

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by thomastjeffery on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:29PM (#26973787)
It sounds like that is what they have been doing.

What they need to do now is tell Verizon that they failed to fulfill their contract, pull their license, and operate their own municipal broadband.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by toss1 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:02PM (#26974152)
Yup. Although, while I'm no longer familiar with the local situation, it seems that the action has more been to sue Verizon and pocket the proceeds from the lawsuits into the general fund, while keeping their actual regulatory big gun in the holster.

Managing lawsuits and paying fines is apparently still cheaper for Verizon than actually installing the fiber.

What I want to know is WHY no regulator or judge has seen fit to actually enforce the requirement sufficiently to change Verizon's behavior.

(Or why they just don't use your suggestion, say they failed, repeatedly, pull the plug, and make their own system. They could pay for a LOT with the profits, even providing better and cheaper service)

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:54PM (#26974075)
New York City government has been all talk and no walk because they also do not want to pony up the sufficient funds to make it happen.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by meragrin_ on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:05PM (#26972244)
> It doesn't support streaming yet, but it hits around 200+ down and 25 up on my phone, so it may get there.

Does that mean the 5g internet is really slow(DSL speed?) or do they actively block streaming? Is there another reason streaming wouldn't be supported even at a decent speed?

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:27PM (#26974437)
I misread the announcement. They don't support a couple specific services (Hulu Live TV) but everything else streams just great from reviews I've read (Netflix, YouTube, regular Hulu, etc).
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by JonLim on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:10PM (#26973587)
Depending on where you live, check and see if you have Natural Wireless[0] available in your building/residence. Recently moved into an apartment that is lucky enough to get their service, and we get gigabit for ~$70 a month.

Have had almost zero issues, and their support has been tremendous.

[0]: https://naturalwireless.com/

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by kortex on Thursday April 29, 2021 @10:45AM (#26981830)
I'm in upstate NY. I've lost track of the number of times I've heard folks complain that there is Verizon fiber a few hundred feet away but when you inquire about getting it to your home, Verizon is just like, "mmm, nah." This is where municipal intervention is most necessary - last mile, nay, last quarter mile.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by 310260 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:20PM (#26971827)
Spectrum (TWC) also likes to get exclusive rights to certain buildings too. Making the problem worse.

On the topic of T-Mobile home internet, it does support streaming. Availability is determined by the network in your local area though.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:28PM (#26974439)
I misread the announcement. They don't support a couple specific services (Hulu Live TV) but everything else streams just great from reviews I've read (Netflix, YouTube, regular Hulu, etc).
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by xedrac on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:16PM (#26972361)
I've found that I almost never get the rates I pay for with Comcast. I'm currently on their 600/35 plan, and I'm lucky to get 200 down and 15 up. So even if Comcast were to roll out "gigabit" everywhere, it would likely be very inferior to municipal fiber.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by tzs on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:16PM (#26974929)
Have you considered switching to a lower speed plan?

If you are only actually getting 200, you might as well switch to the 200 plan and save $20/month.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by ortusdux on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:46PM (#26971440)
My best option currently is Wave Broadband, with 940/20 costing 100$/mo. I pay an extra 8$/mo for 940/25. The tech installing my line checked my signal and said that they could support 940/940, but they wont offer it in my area. I am pricing the cost of a fiber run that after install will be 1000/1000 for 60$/mo. I would gladly pay $3k to hook-up.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by GloriousKoji on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:57PM (#26971579)
With comcast in my area the unofficial strategy is to require you to sign up for a new plan every year to slowing tick down your speed and increase costs. If you stick with your old plan the monthly doubles. Right now I'm paying $60 for 60/3.5 with comcast. A few years ago it was $30 for 100/3.5 I have no other real options, it's gross.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by hellbannedguy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:56PM (#26972152)
I heard threw the grapevine Xfinity (comcast) has given up on trying to compete with streaming services.

Their strategy is just charge more for everything, and make ordering services compliced.

Going on their website to just get basic cable, and low speed internet is very hard.

They push packages--hoping you will never realize when the deal ends.

They rely on senior citizens who just pay the bill, and are not technical enough to even shop around--if they have a choice? Most households don't.

Comcast should be required to have have simple billing, and simple ording of service

That could be taken care of the next time your local government ok's their next franchise agreement. It's not a franchise. It's some agreement government has with them.

Be careful calling Xfinity (comcast) for anything. The calls are routed overseas, and those employees main function is pushing package deals. Don't fall for it. They try to get the customer to agree on voice, so they have evidence.

1. I'm ok with their internet service, except for the price, and lack of competition.

2. The cable tv service is subpar. I have had checkering for ever. I gave up on getting it corrected. After three visits from third party vendors it's still not right. (This third party vendor was working 6 days a week, and was required to lease his service truck for $250/week.).

3. If you do have a lousy connection, it might be partially related to a filter Comcast put on years ago, but never took off. (The new filters are fine, but a certain brand of an older one is bad. I just threw it out so I can't give the part number. If you have voice remote, make sure it's on the right three splitter. I vagly remember it on the outlet with the lowest resistance?

4. I believe Comcast knows they are pushing too much through that coaxial. I believe they preparing for a class action lawsuit, but might not care?

5. I only put up with Comcast because there's no real competition where I reside. Xfinity's agreements with local municipalities needs to be nixed.

6. Comcast promised to not cut off service during the pandemic, but lied.

7. Comcast offers Hotspots. Your router could be the hotspot, and they don't have to tell you. (I don't believe their is any danger to this practice though.)

I would love it that infrastructure bill did away with Xfinity. They provide very few good paying jobs. I would like to see free internet provided to every American, even the wealthy.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Alupis on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:29PM (#26973121)
My comcast bill is $70 a month for 1000Mbps down / 36Mbps up. Pretty happy actually... and my area has no municipal ISP, and the only other option is AT&T's DSL variant.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by mjevans on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:04PM (#26973516)
Your area has no Broadband Internet competition. You have extremely poor upload and presumably a cap that you can go over by accidentally leaving a video streaming service tab open on.

How are you happy again? It sounds like you're happy to be in an abusive relationship rather than none at all.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Alupis on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:24PM (#26973728)
I'm happy because it satisfies my needs for a reasonable price. I don't have a use for 1Gbps uploads... mostly nobody does actually... and I stream a lot of 1080p content, which comes nowhere near the "data cap" any month of the year.

Perhaps things would be different if I were streaming 4k, but I'm not - and that would only be an issue with a data cap (I agree, data caps are absurd).

BTW, the limit on the upload is a physical issue with cable lines and the DOCSIS protocol... I don't feel it's realistic to demand fiber to everyone's home when nearly nobody has an actual use-case for symmetrical home connections...

Lastly, getting the government involved in maintaining lines to everyone's homes is a disaster waiting to happen. What infrastructure is the government doing an excellent job maintaining as it is? With salary caps on staffers, and the inability to terminate underperforming employees - municipal-owned lines and/or ISP's will start out great, and over time suffer the same bureaucratic disease the rest of the government already has.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:57PM (#26974101)
>BTW, the limit on the upload is a physical issue with cable lines and the DOCSIS protocol... I don't feel it's realistic to demand fiber to everyone's home when nearly nobody has an actual use-case for symmetrical home connections...

Nobody had a use case until a family of 4 needs to work and school from home simultaneously or upload video. Somehow, we had a use case for delivering people ad laden garbage tv shows via cable, but something like fiber internet which might actually be used for productivity and creativity is not worthy of public support?

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Alupis on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:15PM (#26974306)
Are you so sure the government can run a high tech ISP better than the private sector? That they will employ the best and brightest and pay them market rates or better?

Or will it just turn into yet another jobs program, filled with sub-par employees that can never be fired for poor performance... While the infrastructure rots away?

Say what you want about Comcast... But my internet never goes down, is always fast, is a reasonable price, and support is readily available within a couple minutes if needed.

Can you say the same for any government run program or infrastructure project?

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:30PM (#26974454)
> Say what you want about Comcast... But my internet never goes down, is always fast, is a reasonable price, and support is readily available within a couple minutes if needed.

I’ve dealt with Comcast in 3 states on both coasts, and I can’t share any of those sentiments. The upload is always garbage.

> Can you say the same for any government run program or infrastructure project?

Yes, I’ve never had to call anyone about my electric, gas, sewage, water, roads, parks, or air. Also, FYI, a government org came up with the internet in the first place.

This trope of “all things government bad” is so lazy. We are lucky in the US to live in a relatively trustworthy society, where the FAA/FDA/CDC/etc have done quite a few things to make our lives pleasant. Obviously they’re not perfect, but by and large the civilian agencies have undoubtedly pushed our quality of life up.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Alupis on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:47PM (#26974654)
Electric - burned down several towns in California 2 years back due to failure to maintain the lines over the last 30 years.

Gas and Sewage rarely require infrastructure upgrades... ie. there's no new home appliance that requires "more" gas than the lines can currently provide (or provided 30 years ago).

Water? What about all the lead in the water issues that were exposed a few years back? Do you think they would have just fixed that if nobody made a big stink about it?

ARPAnet has literally nothing to do with how commercial (or municipal) ISP's operate today... not sure what point you're trying to make.

FAA has been attempting to upgrade ATC services nation-wide for years and years... still hasn't happened. Plus they've outsourced certifications of new aircraft to the manufacturer (because they don't have the staff to do it themselves, because they don't pay as well as private companies) which led to the Boeing 737-MAX thing...

CDC is now a political organization spouting whatever the current president wants (at least under Trump and Biden)

FDA - shills for the beef and corn industries...

None of your examples are good.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:50PM (#26974694)
> Electric - burned down several towns in California 2 years back due to failure to maintain the lines.

That was a private entity. (The same one that also was on proabtion for felonies for killing people and causing widespread damage with its gas operations not long before.)

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Alupis on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:55PM (#26974745)
Is it though? They can't do so much as paint their trucks without government approval.

I'll admit, utilities are a bizarre hybrid at best - however it was the government's state level utility commission that approved the non-maintenance plans for decades.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:37PM (#26975137)
I consider utilities as part of government. They private part is just so government officials can use them as a scapegoat. For example, not letting PGE raise prices to do proper maintenance, but then also blaming them when it caused wildfires. Of course, voters will vote for the politician that promises to keep costs down and keeps more money in their pockets.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:36PM (#26975129)
I do not understand what the purpose of pointing out specific deficiencies is after I already pointed out that there were deficiencies.

I know myself and many other people feel safe traveling via air, buying food at the grocery store, drinking tap water, are not worried about our houses burning down, and trust the vaccines will help protect us.

Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by Analemma_ on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:53PM (#26971529)
Wave Broadband literally doubled my bill out of the blue last November-- not because a trial pricing period ended or anything, but just because they could: I was in an apartment building where they were the only option. It's irrelevant now because shortly after that I moved to a different location, but they're just as bad as Comcast. Private ISPs delenda est.
Re:The number of cities with municipal broadband has jumped ... by heavyset_go on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:05PM (#26973530)
> And that's right, Comcast gives 35 Mbps upload, if you are lucky! And data caps.

Before I switched last year, I only got 10Mbps up from Comcast.