Re:Good puzzle: 12 balls, 1 a diff weight, find in 3 uses of...
by tomp on Saturday June 25, 2011 @08:15PM
(#2697021)
No way.
Each experiment gives has 3 possible outcomes: left, right, and balanced. So in 2 experiments you can a maximum of 9 = 3*3 different outcomes. That's not enough to pick one ball out of 12.
If you have 3 experiments, you have 27 outcomes. You need 24 to tell which ball, + heavier/lighter, and 3 outcomes are impossible.
Edit: impossible or redundant, depending of your strategy.
Re:Good puzzle: 12 balls, 1 a diff weight, find in 3 uses of...
by shasta on Saturday June 25, 2011 @08:07PM
(#2697002)
Bzz. You can't do what you claim in two weighings (gauranteed)
Re:Good puzzle: 12 balls, 1 a diff weight, find in 3 uses of...
by TomasSedovic on Saturday June 25, 2011 @08:15PM
(#2697018)
Sigh, you're right. Thank's for the correction. I guess it's true that nothing good happens after 2AM (my local time).
So the final constraint (not mentioned in the title) is to find out whether the anomalous ball is heavier or lighter than the rest.
That's where the third measure comes in.