News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by thaumaturgy on Saturday June 25, 2011 @04:35AM (#2695271)
I want to finish this conversation with just one point, which I'll try to make as clearly as possible. I started this thread with a post that included the question, "Why don't more poor people clean up their neighborhoods?"

I was being rhetorical, but your comments here are a fine example of one of the reasons why they don't: lack of a sense of ownership.

Let's set aside for a moment all of the other factors into why poor neighborhoods tend to be run-down and crime-ridden -- lack of resources, hunger, hopelessness, crime, drugs -- and imagine a neighborhood filled with perfectly rational poor people.

We'll take Bob as an example. Bob rents a house for slightly less than he can afford from a landlord that, for whatever reason, is not interested in fixing the place up and demanding a higher rent. Maybe it's because the landlord also doesn't have the funds; maybe it's because all the other places in the neighborhood are run down too, so the landlord could never realize as much value from improvements.

In Bob's neighborhood, none of the houses are freshly painted, because it's in nobody's best personal interest to do it, because they don't own the places. None of the yards are weeded or landscaped, the plumbing leaks, and the wiring is hazardous. Bob commits as little of his own resources to his house, because it doesn't belong to him.

Eventually, the neighborhood becomes the victim of its own disrepair, and is no longer worth investing any money in at all. Bob, being perfectly rational, simply moves into a similar situation at another neighborhood.

A wealthy investor shows up, purchases the homes for the rather low amounts that they command, from landlords happy to be rid of them and getting anything at all for them, and kicks out the tenants who simply move into other neighborhoods and repeat the pattern. The investor razes the miserable houses to the ground, which is probably the right thing to do at that point, and builds whatever their market research firm tells them is most valuable there -- a shopping center, parking, condominiums.

This, indeed, is a cycle that is being played out every day all over the U.S.; I've personally seen it in more places than I could easily recall.

But, I question that system. I think, if Bob weren't a rational actor, if instead he moved into a community and decided to behave as though it belonged to him as much as anyone else there, and subsequently started fixing little things here and there -- and then his neighbors did the same, because they didn't want to suddenly have the worst place on the block, and so on -- then, perhaps, poor people could discover that they can afford to live in nice neighborhoods after all.

G'night.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by Tichy on Saturday June 25, 2011 @05:08AM (#2695314)
I hope it is clear that I don't mean to attack you, I am just trying to understand.

We seem to agree that sense of ownership is the problem - and to me it is real, as those poor people really don't own the place they live in.

You are right that there could be a problem with people staying poor indefinitely and things only getting worse over time.

On the other hand, maybe the problem isn't "how can poor people live in nice places" but "how can poor people be less poor"? For example, apparently the poor people in your story seem to be good at renovating houses. Why shouldn't they be paid for it and hence become less poor (equivalently, be allowed to live in a nice house with lower rent in exchange for renovating said house). It seems it would cost the landlords nothing to give them a job, it is a win win situation.

I do think, or rather fear, that capitalism (or any real world instance of it) has some loopholes which might lead to the whole system collapsing, that is, everything belonging to just a few and the rest being poor. I am not sure that scenario is really happening (I just don't know), but there seem to be some signs of it.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by thaumaturgy on Saturday June 25, 2011 @01:18PM (#2696067)
> I hope it is clear that I don't mean to attack you, I am just trying to understand.

I didn't feel attacked at all. :-) Thanks for the conversation.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by anamax on Saturday June 25, 2011 @12:01PM (#2695906)
> In Bob's neighborhood, none of the houses are freshly painted, because it's in nobody's best personal interest to do it, because they don't own the places. None of the yards are weeded or landscaped, the plumbing leaks, and the wiring is hazardous. Bob commits as little of his own resources to his house, because it doesn't belong to him.

> But, I question that system. I think, if Bob weren't a rational actor

The above tells us more about your definition of "rational" than anything else. You're envy driven.

The guy above defines "rational" differently - he's greed driven. He fixes up the place that he rents because of the value that he gets.

IMHO, you're too concerned about what someone else gets. You don't even see how anyone else can think differently, hence your label "rational".

Envy is the stupid sin. It's the only sin that doesn't get you anything.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by gnosis on Saturday June 25, 2011 @03:39PM (#2696373)
Envy driven? It sounds to me like he's driven by altruism and a simple desire to make the place he lives more pleasant.

I really don't know where you got envy from.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by anamax on Saturday June 25, 2011 @11:10PM (#2697265)
Reread the exchange. ("The guy above" is not Bob.)

I'm responding to someone who thinks that it's irrational to fix up one's own house when others get significant benefit.

The person who is doing the fixup is doing it because he gets significant benefit, regardless of what other people get. The person criticizing thinks that Bob, who won't do work that benefits others without being compensated, is rational.

That's envy-talk.

Envy is worrying about what other people have/get. Greed is worrying about what you get. A greedy person will do things that benefit himself even if other people benefit without paying. An envious person won't.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by thaumaturgy on Sunday June 26, 2011 @06:15AM (#2697769)
Just for the record, you got that about as wrong as you possibly could -- to such an extent that I'm scratching my head at your interpretation of what I wrote -- but I can't clarify it any further because I've already made this as clear as I can.

edit: it sounds like you may not be aware that "rational actor" means a specific thing in microeconomics. See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_choice_theory . Specifically, in order for Bob to qualify as a rational actor, he must act in such a way as to maximize his benefit, where his benefit is defined in objective terms of monetary value. i.e., "I like having flowers in my yard" does not qualify as a benefit, thus a rational actor would not spend money to put flowers in their yard. The entire point of all that was to describe, in as simple of an example as I could construct, why I think that behaving only as rational actors -- i.e., measuring our benefits only in terms of monetary value -- can lead to undesirable outcomes, and why acting irrationally -- again, in the sense of microeconomics -- can lead to better outcomes for all involved.

I can't figure out where I went wrong in stating all that the last time 'round.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by Tichy on Sunday June 26, 2011 @10:02AM (#2698014)
"Specifically, in order for Bob to qualify as a rational actor, he must act in such a way as to maximize his benefit, where his benefit is defined in objective terms of monetary value. i.e., "I like having flowers in my yard" does not qualify as a benefit"

If that truly is the definition of rational, then sorry, economics is sorely mistaken. Or at least the people who conduct economics that way. I always assumed it was clear that "monetary gain" is simply a placeholder for value gained. Of course "I like having flowers in my yard" does qualify.

Thinking in terms of monetary gain really makes no sense, especially since money doesn't actually have any value. It only has value if you can use money to put flowers in your yard, if you so desire.

I am not an economist but a mathematician by training, so I am not sure what economists are thinking. But they can't (all) be that stupid. Mathematically it is obvious that using such a strict definition of value (monetary gain) is unnecessary and hence should be done away with.

That said, I have problems following the "envy driven vs greed driven" argument.

Re:Why don't rich people do more awesome things? by anamax on Sunday June 26, 2011 @12:14PM (#2698299)
>>"Specifically, in order for Bob to qualify as a rational actor, he must act in such a way as to maximize his benefit, where his benefit is defined in objective terms of monetary value. i.e., "I like having flowers in my yard" does not qualify as a benefit"

> If that truly is the definition of rational, then sorry, economics is sorely mistaken.

You're too kind - if that's the definition of "rational" that economics uses, economics is fundamentally useless.

> That said, I have problems following the "envy driven vs greed driven" argument.

My apologies.

"Greed" is concern with what you have. "Envy" is concern with what other people have.

A greedy person will do something that benefits himself regardless of whether it benefits others. An envious person will not do something that benefits himself if he thinks that other people get too much benefit from that thing.